3 min read

SCARBOROUGH – The Scarborough Town Council has abandoned a proposal to retain part of the Wentworth Middle School for use as a community center if a replacement school is built.

A school-building committee will now work on a construction proposal that residents will vote on in November. If approved, the Wentworth school would be torn down once the new school is ready to open.

Some residents had hoped a portion of the 48-year-old Wentworth school could be retained for community use and connected to the new school. But opponents said that would create design problems. The newly built portion might also have encroached on wetlands, requiring a mitigation effort that could have added $500,000 to the cost of the project.

Judith Roy, the council chair, said she supported retaining part of the existing school because many residents have for years urged the town to build a community center, primarily for use by teenagers and seniors. She said the school, which has had air quality issues and recently had to be cleared of asbestos, could have met that need.

“If we could make it work, it would tide us over for 10 years or maybe more,” she said.

Roy noted that no one disputes the need for a new intermediate school to serve third-, fourth- and fifth-graders. Besides the asbestos issue, some utility tunnels beneath the existing school leak and mold has formed. The overcrowded school also uses five classroom trailers, she said.

Advertisement

Roy said councilors agreed going into Wednesday’s meeting that they would abide by whatever consensus they reached — there was no official vote.

The decision to go with an all-new school clears the way for the building committee to get back to work, Town Manager Tom Hall said.

He said the 40-member panel needed the Wentworth school’s future decided before it could work on a preliminary design for a new school. Now, Hall said, the goal is to come up with sketches and cost estimates by June so voters will have several months to consider the plans before voting on a bond issue in November.

There are no cost estimates yet. In 2006, voters turned down a proposed $38.5 million replacement for Wentworth. But a separate $16.5 million bond for renovating Scarborough Middle School was also on the ballot that year and some believe the total cost was just too much.

“There are all sorts of theories for why it failed in 2006,” Hall said. “It may have just been taxpayer fatigue.”

Hall, who didn’t work in Scarborough then, said members of the building committee have vowed to come up with a more frugal design this time.

Advertisement

The new school is also likely to have some features designed for both school and community use, he said. The cafeteria and gym could both be built to accommodate public uses, he said.

Roy said there are other options for a community center. Scarborough needs to replace its public safety building on Oak Hill and the old structure could be put to community use once it has been replaced.

Staff Writer Edward D. Murphy can be contacted at 791-6465 or at:

emurphy@pressherald.com

 

Ed covers the City of Westbrook and business stories for the Portland Press Herald.

Comments are no longer available on this story