3 min read

– On a dark Sunday night, I dropped off my truck for its annual state inspection. If you live in Maine, you know that the cost of “the sticker” is $18. Remember that — you’ll appreciate it in a minute.  

Having had some other work done on the truck recently, I naively thought that I already paid my fair share to automotive aftermarket for 2011, and assumed that there’d be nothing to pay beyond the $18.

Monday morning, the phone rang. It was Bob from the inspection station. 

Do you know how you can tell by the tone of a person’s voice that they’re about to give you bad news?

First, Bob paused. Then he asked me if I was sitting down. I confirmed that I was. Then he described three specific items that would need to be replaced, in order to grant me that coveted state inspection sticker.   

I asked Bob to give me the total cost. He read off a number. I’m not including that number in this column, because I never want to see it again. But I will tell you that it was more than what my father paid for the new family station wagon in 1975.

Advertisement

Despite the initial shock, I thought that Bob did a pretty good job of delivering some pretty bad news.

We all have to play the messenger from time to time, delivering bad news to clients, employees or even family members. But if we do it the way Bob did, being “the messenger” can be less dangerous, and can actually help us to build greater customer loyalty.

Bob followed three basic rules for delivering bad news: Communicate bad news early, choose your words carefully and help the client to transition past the pain stage.

COMMUNICATE BAD NEWS EARLY

When you have customers, clients or patients waiting for information, the longer they wait, the longer false hope can take root. And it can hurt pretty badly when well-rooted hope is torn from the soil of optimism. 

But if you set the expectations early that there will likely be bad news, there’s less trauma for the customer to absorb. And less trauma for the customer typically means less trauma for you. (Or, as an old sales manager of mine once said, “If you have to eat a bad-tasting sandwich, eat it fast, in a single bite, and get it over with!”)

Advertisement

CHOOSE YOUR WORDS CAREFULLY

What you say and how you say it will have a big impact on the customer’s reaction. Avoid words that are likely to trigger an emotional response; instead, use words that are more collaborative.

For example:

n Instead of “You should have …,” try “We can work this out together.”

n Instead of “You can’t …” try “One alternative might be …”

n Instead of “I can’t …,” try “What I can do is … “

Advertisement

Your choice of words will not only influence the customer’s immediate reaction, but also set the tone for your ongoing relationship with that customer. So choose carefully!

DON’T LEAVE THE CUSTOMER IN PAIN

Giving a customer bad news can be like dropping an anvil in their lap. You can drop it, walk away and leave the customer to deal with the issue that, technically, they own. Or you can help the customer handle the burden, by presenting them with a less painful solution.

Take time to research some sound alternative solutions to offer the customer, solutions that won’t hurt so much.

That’s what Bob did. He recommended an independent garage that could do the work for a lot less. A little more than the $18 cost for the inspection sticker, but a lot less than the cost of the 1975 family station wagon. 

Bob may have “given away” a little business in the short term, but he absolutely will earn that back from me over the long term.

Bad news will be bad news, if you let it. But with immediate delivery, careful word choice and a thoughtful solution, bad news can generate good news, for both your client and your business.

 

Comments are no longer available on this story