ALFRED — The driver of a dump truck who fatally struck a teenager skateboarding across a Sanford street two years ago told police he thought the boy was going to stop before entering the roadway.
“He said he would have taken a side street if he had to do it over again,” Sanford Police Officer Paul Shaw said Mark Stuart told him during interviews following the July 13, 2012 crash that killed 15-year-old Corey Cabana.
Shaw was one of several people testifying at York County Superior Court Thursday in the trial of Mark Stuart and Stuart, Torno and Stuart Inc. Both Stuart, who was the driver of the truck and president of the company, along with the company itself, are charged with manslaughter. Justice John O’Neil is hearing the case. Both Stuart and the company have waived their right to a jury trial.
Shaw, in testimony Thursday morning, said Stuart told him he was approaching the hill by Sleeper’s Market on Lebanon Street, which is also Route 202, and saw a boy on a skateboard headed toward the crosswalk. He said the boy had his head down. Stuart told Shaw he began to apply his brakes.
Assistant District Attorney Thad West asked Shaw if Stuart had said whether he conducted a pre-drive inspection before driving the truck, which was later found to have faulty brakes, among several other deficiencies. The truck’s inspection had expired six months before the crash, and according to an inspection report issued after the crash, it had 15 deficiencies, nine of which were considered “out of service” violations, which meant the truck could not be legally operated until repaired.
Shaw said Stuart told him he should have inspected the truck, and then later told Shaw he’d looked it over.
Shaw said Stuart first told him Cabana didn’t stop and then later said he appeared to pause, and that Stuart thought the boy saw the truck approaching and was going to stop.
In response to a question by defense counsel Peter DeTroy, Shaw said Stuart told him “he was standing on his brakes,” was yelling at the boy and veered to the right to try and avoid him.
There were a number of other witnesses called to the stand as the state’s case proceeded Thursday morning.
Matthew Winters was a passenger in a vehicle driven by Kevin Hartford. The men testified separately. Winters said he saw Cabana, who appeared to be looking down at a cellphone or iPod in his hand as he started to skateboard across the road.
“He entered the road and never looked up and obviously never saw (the truck) coming,” said Winters.
He said following the collision, the driver of the truck got out, looking distraught.
Hartford said he was driving about 20 miles per hour when he came up behind the dump truck. He said he saw Cabana on the skateboard and wondered if he was going to stop.
William Denoncour of North Berwick was called as a witness by the defense. He was in the parking lot at Sleeper’s Market that day, heard a scream, and saw the collision.
“I saw the young man grabbing for the side of the dump truck. He bounced off and ended up under the wheels,” said Denoncour, who said he didn’t see the boy or the truck before they collided.
Joseph Perron, who worked for Stuart, Torno and Stuart off and on for 17 years before he left for another job in March 2012, several months before the crash, testified he told the Stuarts the dump truck, a 1997 International, had broken springs and that the brakes were out of adjustment when he was plowing snow for the company. He said he continued to drive the truck until he left to take another job.
Jackie Wickham was called as a witness by the defense. She said she was parked outside Sleeper’s Market when she heard the driver of the dump truck yelling, “I can’t stop that fast. Don’t go.” Then she looked and saw the driver try to swerve, and the boy hit the side of the truck. She said her mother, who had been an emergency medical technician, went to the boy’s aid. She said in her opinion, the driver did “everything he could” to avoid hitting the boy.
DeTroy, the defense counsel, asked Wickham if she felt the driver had time to stop.
“No, the dump truck was filled with gravel. That takes a lot more time to stop than a car,” she said.
Witness Craig Gorham said he saw Cabana come down the hill on Nason Street, and that he didn’t put his foot down to slow the skateboard.
“He never looked, he kept going straight across. He never looked right or left,” said Gorham. He said the boy slowed somewhat, because the hill flattens out, and he heard someone yelling from a dump truck, and saw the collision.
Testimony was scheduled to continue this morning, and the trial was expected to conclude sometime later today. It is unclear whether O’Neil will render a verdict at the trial’s conclusion or at a later time.
— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less