ALFRED — York County Superior Court Justice John O’Neil will render a decision Monday on whether the driver of a dump truck and the company of which he is president are guilty of manslaughter in the death of a skateboarding teenager in Sanford two years ago.
The four-day bench trial of Mark Stuart and Stuart, Torno and Stuart Inc. wound down mid-afternoon Friday.
Stuart, 53, was the driver of the dump truck that hit Corey Cabana, 15, who was skateboarding in a crosswalk on Lebanon Street, which is also Route 202, on July 13, 2012. The boy had come down Nason Street and skated into the crosswalk. He was wearing earbuds, and witnesses said he looked neither right or left, but was looking down ”“ some thought at a cell phone or iPod. He died later that day in the hospital.
The brakes on the truck, which was carrying a load of crushed stone, were found to be faulty and the truck had a number of other deficiencies. Prosecutor Thaddeus West said that Stuart had been previously told by an employee that there were issues with the truck’s brakes.
Typically, said West, in motor vehicle manslaughter cases, there is discussion about the operator’s ability to control their vehicle.
“This vehicle has no room for error, so a decision to operate it is invariably connected to (Stuart’s) ability to control it,” he said.
West, in closing arguments Friday afternoon, said the situation could have ended differently if Stuart had reacted differently and if the truck had more braking power. Stuart’s actions that day rose to the level of conscious disregard and the decision to operate the vehicle was compounded by a series of other factors, which is why both Stuart and the company should be found guilty of manslaughter, West concluded.
Peter DeTroy, Mark Stuart’s defense counsel, said there’s no question the truck was not in adequate condition. DeTroy said Stuart admitted to police that he must have missed something when he looked at the truck prior to driving it that day. But he insisted carelessness does not mean Stuart was criminally negligent.
“Maybe (he didn’t take) due care, bit it is not the kind of gross indifference we require,” said DeTroy, in his closing argument.
“We admit the brakes were deficient, but they were not the cause of the death,” said George “Toby” Dilworth, defense counsel for Stuart, Torno and Stuart, Inc. He said Cabana was not a pedestrian and that skateboards are treated the same as bicycles under Maine law. Cabana’s failure to stop at the end of Nason Street and to skateboard into the crosswalk were the cause of his death, said Dilworth.
Earlier in the day, the court heard from Richard McAllister, a crash reconstructionist called by the defense. Using calculations he made, McAllister testified that the truck could not have stopped even if the brakes had been perfect. His testimony differed from that of Sanford Police Officer Scott Foisy, who reconstructed the crash. Foisy, using his own calculations, earlier in the trial said if Stuart had braked before he yelled at Cabana to stop, he could have stopped the truck.
Members of both the Cabana family and the Stuart family were in the courtroom throughout the trial.
— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less