3 min read

PORTLAND — Former York County Judge of Probate Robert M.A. Nadeau told justices of the Maine Supreme Judicial Court on Friday that he recognizes his actions were intemperate when he ordered the Register of Probate to abruptly reschedule cases after county commissioners refused to increase his salary and provide more court time in 2015.

“My goal was always to avoid errors of any sort and do what best for users of the court,” Nadeau told the justices regarding his behavior in that situation and others for which he is under scrutiny.

Nadeau. who lost the November election in a three-way race, represented himself in oral arguments before the justices in connection with complaints filed by a judicial oversight panel in 2015, during his tenure as a judge.

The hearing had been rescheduled from Thursday because of the snowstorm that day. Audio of oral arguments is live-streamed.

The complaints by the Committee on Judicial Responsibility and Disability regard actions Nadeau took in appointing attorneys, the court schedule and other matters during his last term as probate judge. In all, Nadeau served four, 4-year terms on the probate bench.

Advertisement

The oversight committee is recommending Nadeau be suspended from practicing law for two years — but that the recommended sanction itself be suspended unless he announces his candidacy for judicial office. The panel also recommends a $10,000 fine.

The oral arguments follow findings by retired Justice Robert Clifford, who last year found that Nadeau acted in “anger and disappointment” and breached judicial canons when his request for additional court hours and an increase in salary were denied.

Clifford acknowledged that, in the long run, Nadeau’s scheduling changes resulted in improvement to the court schedule, but  he wrote that “it is the impetuous manner in which the initial changes were made that resulted in the violations.”

In 2015, county commissioners denied Nadeau’s request for more hours and a boost in his salary from 64 hours a month and a $54,000 annual salary to $90,000 a year for three days a week or $119,000 for a full-time position.

The same night his request was denied, Nadeau ordered changes to the probate court schedule in emails to Probate Register Carol Lovejoy.

Chief Justice Leigh Saufley questioned Nadeau about the situation. 

Advertisement

“All courts have resource problems,” said Saufley, in part. “As soon as they voted not to expand the hours, you were firing off emails. Every judge knows that is a dangerous time; when you’ve got bad news you don’t write, you don’t make decisions, you don’t make changes.”

Committee on Judicial Responsibility and Disability Director Cabanne Howard said the crux of the matter involving the rescheduling wasn’t the speed in which it occurred, but Nadeau’s retaliatory motive.

One of the justices pointed out that the chief justice frequently asks the Legislature for more resources.

Howard said the difference is that with Nadeau, the request was for his personal benefit. Howard responded similarly when the justices asked him about Nadeau’s suggestions to litigants that they could contact county commissioners if they had concerns about court resources.

Nadeau, for his part, told the justices that the volume of cases in York County is similar to Cumberland County, where the probate judge practices nearly full-time.

Nadeau pointed out that he reinstated seven attorneys he had initially removed from an appointments list once he received a judicial ethics opinion. Four of the attorneys had once practiced with Nadeau and three worked with his former associates.

Advertisement

He said his decisions were not intended to be intemperate, but were made for budgetary reasons.

As to the rescheduling, Nadeau said he’d sent an email to Lovejoy about the schedule three years before and had discussed a need for a schedule change two weeks prior to his April 2015 meeting with county commissioners.

“My goal was always to avoid errors of any sort and do what best for users of the court.” he said.

The justices will issue a decision at a future date.

Nadeau’s history includes a recent 30-day suspension and reprimand by the Maine Supreme Judicial  Court in connection with a 2014 complaint by a judicial oversight panel, which alleged Nadeau breached judicial canons in his handling of social media and in a letter he wrote to an attorney concerning a protection from harassment case he initiated against his former fiancee.

— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.