BIDDEFORD — Earlier this month, Maine Supreme Judicial Court Associate Justice Joseph J. Jabar ordered the temporary suspension of a Biddeford attorney. This is the second suspension this year for Scott Giese, who had a private practice in Biddeford for several years.
Among the reasons for the new suspension, according to court documents, is that additional complaints have been made against Giese and he has been summonsed for theft.
Giese, who was admitted to the Maine Bar in 2008, had initially been suspended from practicing law for about 2 1/2 months, from Jan. 2 to March 19.
In the new order, issued on April 4, there is no end date of when the suspension would be lifted.
The order states that Giese be suspended from practicing law in Maine “until further order of this court.”
According to court documents, “Giese appears to have committed numerous violations of the Maine Rules of Professional Conduct, thereby serving as an imminent threat to clients, the public and to the administration of justice.”
In the expedited petition for temporary suspension filed against Giese by the Maine Board of Overseers of the Bar on April 1, four additional complaints have been filed with the board since a Jan. 6 disciplinary hearing, three by clients and one by a former employee.
In addition, according to the petition, the board clerk has received numerous calls regarding Giese’s alleged neglect of other clients and failure to return files.
The petition states that Giese has also failed to make arrangements to make payment on two fee refund awards issued on Jan. 2 by the Fee Arbitration Commission.
“More concerning,” according to the petition, “is the fact that Giese was recently summonsed for theft due to his alleged shoplifting of two items from the Biddeford Walmart. That event and others cause the board to question Giese’s personal and professional judgment.
“While it is clear that Attorney Giese has experienced extreme personal distress,” the petition states, “his violation of the professional conduct rules threaten irreparable injury to his clients and the public.”
“There are concerns he might cause harm to clients’ cases if he were allowed to practice again,” said Acting Board Clerk Zachary Smith.
Smith said the grievances against Giese are still coming in, and the board is only in the investigatory stage.
However, he said, “The concerns are serious enough that they didn’t want him to take on new clients or make promises to old clients.”
In addition, Smith said, the new complaints made against Giese seem to follow a “pretty similar pattern of behavior” of the earlier complaints.
Giese’s earlier sanction stemmed from multiple violations of the Maine Rules of Professional Conduct, which Jabar had described as “serious and troubling.”
The prior violations regarded five counts.
In count one, Ingrid Horvat alleged Giese agreed to a highly contested parental rights agreement without her consent.
In count two, attorney Amy Fairfield’s complaint reported Giese’s unauthorized contact with Fairfield’s family law client.
In count three, a grievance complaint filed by Diane Gonneville and Katrena Guiod regarded Giese filing an unmeritorious lawsuit against the two on behalf of a family with which he had a personal conflict.
In count four, Tammy Mutombo alleged that Giese neglected her estate matter, charged an excessive fee and failed to communicate.
In count five, former client Geoffrey Reese complained that Giese failed to prosecute Reese’s criminal appeal, which was pending in Maine Supreme Judicial court.
In issuing the earlier sanction, Jabar wrote that Giese’s violations “indicate difficulties with Giese’s ability to manage his practice and properly communicate with clients.”
Jabar added that it appeared Giese expanded his practice too fast.
“As a result,” wrote Jabar, “clients were neglected and legal matters were not properly attended to.”
In the earlier case, Giese said he was largely in agreement with a negotiated resolution of the matter.
At that time, he told the Journal Tribune, “I didn’t fight it,” he said. “I consented to everything.”
Earlier, Giese blamed personal problems as the reason for the difficulties with his practice.
“I got too involved in family chaos,” he said.
Giese could not be contacted prior to press time to discuss the most recent order.
— Staff Writer Dina Mendros can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 324 or dmendros@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less