5 min read

ALFRED — A move by the state judiciary to unclog the criminal docket in York County is being viewed with dismay by some area police chiefs, who say dismissing arrest warrants issued before 2007 may mean some crime victims won’t see justice. As well, they say the move could hamper investigation of new crimes.

State Court Administrator James T. Glessner, in a letter to Biddeford Police Chief Roger Beaupre Wednesday, said the Maine Judicial Branch has been working with the York County District Attorney’s Office to improve the process for handling criminal cases in preparation for a unified criminal docket. According to judiciary spokeswoman Mary Ann Lynch, the new docketing system is expected to be in place in York County early next year.

“As part of the implementation process … very old cases, meaning cases that are more than seven years old, and as old as 30 and 40 years, are being reviewed to determine if they can still be prosecuted,” Glessner wrote.

“For serious misdemeanors, (like) OUI, assault, domestic violence and all felonies, the cases are being sent to the district attorney’s office for review,” Glessner said. “That office can then determine whether witnesses are still available, whether police reports can be located, whether evidence is still available and whether the case can still be prosecuted. For matters that the district attorney’s office wishes to continue to pursue, it may file motions to retain those cases on the court’s docket.”

Glessner said misdemeanor cases like disorderly conduct, unregistered motor vehicles, shoplifting, etc. are being reviewed to see if the charging officers are still alive and available. If not, a dismissal without prejudice, which means a case can be re-filed if it is later determined it can be successfully prosecuted, will be entered, he said.

Advertisement

He said each old case is being individually reviewed and considered before any action is taken.

“There is no blanket order to dismiss all warrants as of an arbitrary date,” Glessner wrote.

And while she sees the merit of dispensing of some cases, York County District Attorney Kathryn Slattery has concerns.

“I strongly feel people should not be rewarded for failing to appear in court,” Slattery said in a phone interview Thursday. “I do agree there is some benefit in clearing up cases for which there is no witness or available officer and we know we will never be able to prosecute. This review is not confined to just those cases.”

Slattery said the process began last week and that some cases have already been dismissed. And while her office is reviewing the more serious misdemeanors and all felonies, she said the court is reviewing the remaining misdemeanor cases. Some won’t be able to be re-filed once they’re dismissed, because of the statute of limitations, she said.

Sanford Police Chief Thomas Connolly pointed out that in most cases, evidence is kept “forever,” and only destroyed in consultation with the district attorney.

Advertisement

He agreed there are some cases that can’t be prosecuted, if for example, the officer has retired and moved across the country, or has died.

“I agree that some can be pared out of the system,” Connolly said, but he pointed out that if the suspect has moved out of state, “that doesn’t mean he won’t come back” to Maine.

“This is another example of how people don’t get justice,” said Connolly. “One of our jobs is to try and get justice for people.”

Biddeford Police Chief Roger Beaupre agreed, and asked how one can explain to the victim of a 2007 crime that their case won’t be prosecuted, but a 2008 case, with a different suspect, will.

And, Beaupre said, old warrants can be useful in locating suspects in new crimes.

“If a warrant (is) 20 to 30 years old, it is difficult at best to prosecute, no one disputes that,” said Beaupre. “But it is not uncommon for a law enforcement officer to use a warrant as an investigative tool, so there is a legitimate reason to arrest someone and broach them on an ongoing investigation.”

Advertisement

“It doesn’t seem right to me,” said York County Sheriff Maurice Ouellette, who was also thinking of the victims.

As well, Ouellette said he wondered why the warrants can’t remain in the system. If someone were arrested on a warrant, the district attorney could review the case at that time to determine if it could be prosecuted, he said, rather than have busy prosecutors review them now.

“We all understand the court is under a tremendous amount of pressure and bursting at the seams,” said Beaupre. “We’re all under the same pressure, from law enforcement to the district attorney, we’re all suffering from budget cuts and fewer people to do the job.”

He said it is not unusual for police to identify a suspect in a case, arrest the suspect on a prior warrant, and determine if the individual can be linked to a new crime or provide information in connection with other crimes, including drug trafficking.

Lynch, the spokeswoman for the judiciary, said the same process took place in Cumberland County in preparation for the unified criminal docket some years ago.

“Some of the old cases in York County are 35-plus years old,”’ Lynch said. “This is a process long overdue, and if we had the resources, should be replicated statewide.”

Advertisement

It is unclear how many old warrants exist; no estimate was available Thursday, Lynch said, because all pre-1999 cases are in paper files and would have to be counted by hand. Biddeford alone has about 200, and Connolly estimated Sanford would have at least as many.

A unified criminal docket means cases will originate in their respective district courts in Biddeford, Springvale and York, but then be transferred to York County Court House, home of the superior court, said Lynch. Currently all trials involving felonies are conducted in Alfred, but only misdemeanors in which there is a request for a jury trial take place there. Lynch said while the target date for the unified docket is early in 2015, any physical changes to current court space “will take some time.”

Beaupre said it is his understanding there will be a meeting between law enforcement and the judiciary on the matter, and he had hoped that would take place before the dismissal process had begun, but that didn’t happen.

Ouellette, the sheriff, wondered if those wanted on warrants for failure to pay state fines will see their cases dismissed.

“Does this mean all those people who have not paid their fine will get a walk?” he asked.

— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.