5 min read

BUXTON — For the last several weeks, Michael Crockett Jr.’s life has been a living nightmare. He was falsely arrested, his life as been threatened, he lost his job and his visiting rights with his daughter have been curtailed.

The 30-year-old Buxton man said he’s not sure how he’ll go forward.

“It feels like I’m stuck in one position,” said Crockett.

He blames Buxton Police for his ordeal, saying they did not adequately investigate his alibi in the case in which he was charged.

Once the alibis were verified for Crockett and two other people arrested and charged with assault and robbery of a 61-year-old Buxton woman, the charges against them were dropped.

Advertisement

“The last thing I want to do is arrest someone who is not guilty of a crime,” said Buxton Police Chief Michael Grovo.

But, he said his department arrested Crockett, along with Stacey Day, 35, of Buxton, and Gregory Hoar, 29, of Gorham, for allegedly assaulting Deborah Nielsen, 61, of Buxton, based on evidence deemed credible at the time that the suspects committed the crimes, and that Nielsen was in further danger.

All three had been charged with Class A felony robbery and felony Class B aggravated assault.

Because of lack of evidence, the charges against Crockett were dropped on May 30. The charges against Day and Hoar were dropped earlier this week.

According to an affidavit by Buxton Officer Andrew Ward, the story began on April 11 when Nielsen returned to her Callahan Road home and interrupted a burglary taking place in her garage.

She was struck on the head and fell to the floor, losing partial consciousness. Plastic ties were used to bind her hands, and her ankles were taped together by two men and a woman.

Advertisement

She was threatened that she would be kicked and her granddaughter would be harmed if she didn’t give her assailants money, according to the affidavit.

Nielsen gave the suspects $5,000.

On May 14, Shaun Webster, 31, who was arrested on unrelated crimes, told Buxton police that Crockett, Day and Hoar assaulted Nielsen, according to the affidavit, and that the suspects were planning to return to Nielsen’s home to hurt her again, because they felt she could identify them.

In his affidavit, Ward said he believed Webster’s statement, because he knew elements of the crime that hadn’t been released to the public, such as that one of the men who assaulted Nielsen wore a Dallas Cowboys hat with a star on it and that the victim had been hit on the head with a belt sander.

In addition, according to the affidavit, the night of the attack, K-9 tracker dogs led directly from the victim’s home to Old Thompson Road, where Day was located.

Day and Hoar were arrested on May 15. Crockett surrendered to York County Chief Deputy Bill King May 18 after hiding in the woods in Cornish for several days.

Advertisement

The manhunt for Crockett was covered extensively by the media.

Because of this coverage, said Crockett, “My name has been tarnished. Everywhere I go, I’m going to have to deal with people thinking I did that …”

Even if they catch the people who assaulted Nielsen, said Crockett, the news stories that say he was a suspect will remain on the Internet.

He said he thinks there will still be many people who think he was Nielsen’s assailant.

Despite his recent hardships, said Crockett, who previously had substance abuse issues, “I’m proud to say I stayed sober.”

“In the short term, it saved my life,” he said. Several people at a Narcotics Anonymous meeting in Portland provided alibis for him.

Advertisement

What he most wants, said Crockett, “is for people to hear I didn’t do it. I’ve never been able to have my side heard.”

He said he appreciates the help of his attorney, Amy Fairfield, who hired private investigator Kevin Cady, who verified alibis not only for Crockett but also for Day and Hoar.

Crockett said he is grateful for the help of Chief Deputy King, and “I’m grateful for the (sheriff’s) officers who apprehended me. They listened to me, and they treated me with respect.”

But, he said, “I’m not a fan of the Buxton PD.”

He said in addition to the wrongful arrest, he doesn’t think the police are taking seriously the two threats to his life that occurred since he was charged with the crime against Nielsen.

Once, said Crockett, he was almost run over by a car, and another time, someone pointed a gun at him and his father.

Advertisement

In addition, he said, the police aren’t taking steps to help him see his daughter. He blames the Buxton department for his loss of rights with his child, because of the wrongful charges against him.

Fairfield said she’s talking to her client to see what remedies they might take, such as the possibility of filing a civil suit against the Buxton Police Department.

“The only reason this case is where it is,” she said, “is because a private investigator was hired who did the work the Buxton Police Department didn’t.”

Fairfield said while Crockett was holed up in the woods, she called Grovo and gave him the names and phone numbers of three people who could provide alibis for her clients.

She said she doesn’t believe police followed up on those alibis.

Grovo said he called the people supplied by Fairfield, but they didn’t return the calls.

Advertisement

“If people aren’t guilty of a crime and are arrested, I feel bad as a human being,” said Grovo.

However, he said, he was acting on information that there was an imminent public safety risk. In that respect, he said, he had a duty to perform.

Grovo said the Nielsen case “is still an active investigation. We’re following up leads.”

The Maine State Police are assisting Buxton Police with the case.

— Staff Writer Dina Mendros can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 324 or dmendros@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.