BIDDEFORD — A year after the restructuring of Maine high school football into two classes ”“ and two years removed from strongly rejecting the notion of moving down to Class B ”“ Biddeford High School is again considering whether it should make the move down from its longtime historical home in Class A.
Biddeford Athletic Director Dennis Walton gave a presentation that he called “a consideration” at the Biddeford School Committee’s meeting Tuesday night looking at the possible reasons and benefits behind a switch from Class A West ”“ where Biddeford has built perhaps the strongest football tradition in the state but has struggled in recent years ”“ to Class B West.
Declining enrollment is the cause for the consideration. Biddeford is expected to have a student population of around 775 come the fall, a full 55 students fewer than just three years ago. Walton cited competitive balance issues that come with playing Class A schools, which are in some cases 400 to 500 ”“ and in Thornton Academy’s case 600 ”“ students larger as a main reason to make the move.
“It’s a very tall task to ask our kids to compete against that,” Walton said. “You can’t help but look at that and wonder if this is where we’re best suited to be for our student athletes. It’s certainly something we have to at least look at.”
Biddeford had the chance to move down to Class B two years ago when the Maine Principals Association moved from a three-class to a four-class system for football. With 830 students at the time, Biddeford fell well below the minimum Class A cutoff of 875 and would have been only the third-largest school in Class B West.
But after an open forum on July 25, 2012 ”“ designed to get community feedback on the possible switch where there was strong and nearly unanimous opposition to dropping down a class ”“ Biddeford decided to petition the MPA to stay in Class A. At the forum, then coach Scott Descoteaux said it would be “completely shameful” and it could lead to a loss of interest in football in the community.
Over the past few months, Walton said he, head football coach Brian Curit, High School Principal Jeremie Sirois and Superintendent Jeremy Ray, among others, had been meeting regularly to revisit the issue and to deliberate on where Biddeford best fit into the classification system.
Curit, who spoke at that community forum two summers ago, was again present on Tuesday night, and said he believed that the Biddeford community would be more open to a move to Class B now that the idea had time to sink in and people were better informed on the issue.
“I think had we done this at the meeting two summers ago, there were people there very passionate about Biddeford football that were stunned that we even fell below the designated number,” Curit said. “Almost everything was done on emotion, and, had we done a presentation like this, people in the audience might have been able to make sense of it.”
Circumstances have also changed. That enrollment of 830 students is already in a steady nosedive, with Ray saying he expected it to be in the range of 720 come 2018. That leaves a move to Class B ”“ either now or in the near future ”“ all but inevitable, Walton said.
“This isn’t a short-term problem, this is a foreseeable future problem,” Walton said. “This is where our enrollment is going to be for quite some time, and we are, enrollment wise, a Class B football program. There’s a reason why there’s enrollment classification figures.”
Walton received positive feedback on the possible move to Class B from nearly every school committee member present at the meeting.
“I fully support moving down to Class B and getting out of Class A,” said committee member Tony Michaud.
Bill Moriarty agreed.
“I fully agree that this is something we should do,” he said.
Moriarty, Ray and Biddeford Mayor Alan Casavant all added that they would like to hear feedback from the Biddeford community on the idea, with Ray saying it’s “not a decision to be made behind closed doors.”
Committee member Tammy Fleurent went a step further, saying the classification issue, especially in regards to safety, shouldn’t be up for debate.
“In no other area would we be able to overlook safety concerns and just say, ”˜Oh, we’re just going to opt out on that and take our chances,’” Fleurent said. “I’m not willing to take our chances.”
Walton, Ray and Curit also cited the safety issue, and the fact that with a smaller pool of players from which to choose, Biddeford has many more two-way players than many of the schools it’s competing against, leading to the possibility of more injuries.
And when players are injured, Walton said it usually means having to bring in a younger player, even a freshman, who may not be ready to compete at the varsity level, or having to move another player out of position to fill that gap. That was the case last season, when a rash of injuries led to Curit having to consistently reshuffle his offensive lineup late in the season.
Walton also stressed that one of the main concerns two years ago was the perception that Biddeford would be moving down from Class A simply due to its win-loss record, and that a move down to Class B meant a loss in prestige for a program that has more Class A state championships than any other school.
“I think we have to change the mentality that we will no longer be a football school just because we’re in Class B,” Walton said. “We have a tremendous tradition, and we will continue to have a tremendous tradition. We’ll just have a different schedule based on what’s fair for our student athletes. People fear that it’s a step down, and it’s not.
The potential loss of the Battle of the Bridge game with Thornton Academy, as well as the loss of traditional Class A York County rivals like Sanford and Massabesic, was another major stumbling block in the way of full support, Walton conceded.
But Curit said new rivalries would be created at the Class B level, and that despite the loss of the TA rivalry, he’d received the support of Thornton head coach Kevin Kezal.
“I look at it about competing,” said Curit, who added in the fact that Biddeford is already competing in Class B at the middle school level, where classification is solely based on numbers.
“Talking with Kevin Kezal about a week ago, we were discussing this, and Kevin was saying how in a few years time, their population will be double what ours is. And he said, ”˜Brian, you’d be crazy not to consider this.’”
Walton said that the next step, if the decision is made to drop down to Class B, is to go to the MPA’s interscholastic management committee with a proposal.
Due to the petitioning up, which requires a school to stay in that class for the next four years, it’s possible that Biddeford may not be able to change classes until the 2017 season.
But Walton said MPA members had told him that there was the strong possibility of Biddeford being able to make the switch sooner. That means that 2014 could possibly be the Tigers’ last season in Class A ”“ an idea that not long ago seemed ludicrous, but is closer and closer to becoming a reality after Tuesday’s meeting.
“Is it fair to our student athletes not to approach the MPA?” Walton said in closing his presentation. “This is about a level playing field for our student athletes.
“If we believe we made a mistake two years ago, it’s only fair to our current student athletes to fix the problem now, not make them have to pay for a decision that might have been wrong.”
— Staff Writer Cameron Dunbar can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 323 or cdunbar@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less