By TAMMY WELLS
Senior Staff Writer
ALFRED — Whether it is located in Alfred or elsewhere, it seems that there’s a desire to deal with all criminal proceedings in York County in one courthouse.
That thought was the prevailing theme emerging from a 90-minute meeting of the newly minted York County Courthouse Advisory Committee Thursday. Nothing was firmly decided at the initial meeting of judges, law enforcement, attorneys, legislators, county representatives and employees of the judicial branch. They’ll meet again Sept. 30.
Many at the session, including York County District Attorney Kathryn Slattery, said they favor one courthouse for criminal proceedings, with matters like traffic offenses, hearings for protection orders and the like taking place at satellite courts.
If the criminal court is to be located in Alfred, a decision will have to be made whether to renovate and expand the existing county-owned York County Court House, build new on the existing site, or build new elsewhere in town.
Some said a new criminal court building should be closer to the turnpike; others said population trends should be discussed. Still, others noted the lack of public transportation that already affects defendants attempting to get to their court appearances.
Sen. Linda Valentino said she isn’t sure Alfred should be the location, either in the existing building or elsewhere. She noted there’s no land for expansion on the current site, there’s no public sewer, no turnpike access and there are political considerations.
Pointing to the age of the current Alfred court house ”“ it was built in 1806 and renovated in 1934 after a fire ”“ she noted difficulties in renovating the structure for today’s technological advances.
“You’ll spend more to renovate than build new,” she said. And if there are political considerations, “the last thing you want is someone fighting you at every Planning Board meeting.”
Cumberland County Courthouse, which operates with a unified criminal docket, utilizes about 15 courtrooms. Maine Supreme Court Chief Justice Leigh Saufley said upwards of 14 courtrooms would be required if all York County criminal proceedings were to take place in one building.
“Go for one building,” said Wells Police Chief Jo-Ann Putnam, who was representing police chiefs in the district. “And 14 courtrooms are not happening here,” she said of the York County Court House building.
The Maine Judicial Branch is moving toward a modified uniform criminal docket in York County sometime next year ”“ modified because, at least initially, some criminal proceedings would continue to take place at the district court level. A unified criminal docket, where all criminal proceedings take place in one court, is in place in eight other Maine counties. That system is hampered here, proponents say, because York County is far-flung and has four courthouses: the district courts in Biddeford, Springvale and York, and the Superior Court, located at the county courthouse in Alfred.
Saufley outlined the current situation. She said the three district courts deal with nearly 17,000 new filings in the 2013 fiscal year, handling everything from criminal proceedings to child protection cases, juvenile family matters, small claims, mental health commitments, protection orders, traffic vicil violations and more. The Superior Court, which handles criminal proceedings and civil cases, had 4,000 new filings in the 2013 fiscal year.
Saufley pointed to deficiencies in the three district court buildings, including lack of prisoner holding areas, not enough courtrooms, limited expansion capabilities, and inadequate space for clerks, among other issues.
The Superior Court has issues, too. The courts use 9,000 square feet of space in the building. Saufley said the building has unsafe and inadequate prisoner holding areas, challenges for court security because there are so many entrances, inadequate conference space, limits to renovations because of its status on the National Historic Register and a number of other inadequacies.
County Manager Greg Zinser pointed out that if the state court were looking to expand its use of the county-owned York County Court House, it has to consider county employees and departments.
York County Commission chairman Sallie Chandler was blunt:
“We have no desire to move our people, and no place to put them,” she said.
“Accessibility is a big concern for me,” said Slattery, the district attorney, pointing out there’s a lack of public transportation and many who have business at the court have no driver’s licenses.
Zinser and York County Sheriff Maurice Ouellette pointed out the county owns 100 acres at the York County Jail site and suggested perhaps a deal could be struck for land.
Under a 1970s agreement, the state courts do not pay rent to the counties for the space they currently occupy, but would be required to pay for renovations and rent if they use more space.
Maine District Court Judge Wayne Douglas said population centers ought to be considered .
“What are the projected population trends?” he asked.
Toward the end of the discussion, Saufley advocated for a criminal court hub, with satellite courts.
“I don’t think York County is going to be happy or well-served without some satellite courts,” she said.
— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less