3 min read

Two York County primary candidates are asking the Maine Commission on Governmental Ethics and Election Practices to waive penalties associated with the late filing of campaign finance reports.

While the prescribed preliminary penalties for both Karen Gerrish and Dana Lajoie are $465 and $979, respectively, the commission staff is recommending the penalties each be reduced to $100. The Maine Commission on Governmental Ethics and Election Practices is expected to decide both matters when they meet Aug. 27. 

Candidates who receive or spend $1,000 or more in the last 13 days before the election are required to file a report of the transaction within 24 hours. Neither did so, but were notified they’d missed the filing when their campaigns filed other reports in July. Both Gerrish and Lajoie then filed the reports.

Commission staff, in documents related to the missteps, said violations of the 24-hour reporting requirement can be serious. 

“Twenty-four-hour reports play an important role in informing the electorate about how money is changing hands in the critical days before an election,” the documents say. But the staff went on to say that in weighing the calculated penalty against the harm done, they recommend a $100 penalty in each of the cases.

Advertisement

Lajoie, the South Berwick Police Chief who came in second in a three-way race for the Democratic nod for York County Sheriff, asked for a waiver due to lack of campaign experience and because he didn’t know the 24-hour report was due, commission documents state.

Lajoie had paid $2,040 for a mailing on June 4, but filed a report 45 days later, when he was notified it hadn’t been received as he was filing a different campaign finance report. He told ethics commission registrar Beth Hudson that he had ordered the mailing May 27, but paid the invoice June 4 and was not aware of the 24-hour reporting process.

“I guess I picked the wrong day to pay the invoice,” he is quoted as saying in documents on file with the ethics commission.

Lajoie said he was a first-time candidate with a first-time treasurer and neither were familiar with the intricacies of election law. Lajoie said he and his treasurer, Jennifer Lajoie, were unaware of any financial reporting obligations other than the May 28, 11-day pre-primary and the July 22, 42-day post-primary requirements. 

In a letter to Director Jonathan Wayne, Lajoie apologized for his and his treasurer’s inexperience, and said the matter was an oversight. He said he could have paid for the mailings with a debit card on May 27 when he ordered them, but instead chose to wait for a check from his campaign account.

Gerrish, who won her GOP primary in District 20, which includes Lebanon, Acton and part of Shapleigh, paid $1,035 for a mailing June 4. Through her attorney, William P. Logan, she asked the penalty be reduced. Logan pointed out that Gerrish is a first-time candidate and has no history of prior violations. In commission documents, he argued that no harm was done, and pointed out the 24-hour requirement had been a key provision of the “matching funds” provision under the Maine Clean Elections Act, so that ethics staff could disperse matching funds to MECA candidates. Now, however, matching funds are not available. As well, he said a mailer is a common expenditure for campaigns. He pointed out the penalty assessed amounts to about one half of the expenditure because of how it is calculated. 

Advertisement

The commission uses 1 percent of the expenditure and multiplies that by the number of days the filing is late to come up with a proposed penalty.

The commission staff disagreed with the contention there was no harm to the public, but agreed the preliminary penalty was disproportionately large relative to the harm done. The staff pointed out that Gerrish and her treasurer, former legislator David Bowles, quickly acknowledged their mistake after they were notified the filing was overdue by 45 days.

The two waiver requests are among several on the commission’s agenda Aug. 27. Among the others are requests for waivers by the Senate Democratic Campaign Committee PAC, the Maine Democratic Party and the Re-election Campaign of Hon. Paul LePage.

— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.