5 min read

Carl Johnson
Carl Johnson
What’s the most professional thing a Major League baseball player can do after a pitcher throws at his head intentionally? Baltimore’s Manny Machado showed the world the answer to that question on last Sunday afternoon when he lined Joe Kelly’s pitch off the center field wall for a double. 

Matt Barnes had thrown a pitch that narrowly missed Machado’s head and struck the barrel of his bat behind his head for a foul ball. Barnes was ejected from the game immediately and replaced by Kelly. Kelly threw Machado an 86 mile an hour slider and he crushed it.

As most fans know, the “attempted beaning” happened as a result of Machado’s slide into second base on Friday night which resulted in an injury to Dustin Pedroia’s leg and ankle.  Machado was on first base when Mark Trumbo grounded to short and the throw beat Machado to second but was too late for a relay to first for the double play.  

After tagging second, Pedroia came off the back of the bag and Machado slid into and over the bag and his lead foot came in contact with Pedroia’s leg. Pedroia immediately went down and had to be helped from the field.

After a conference and review, the umpires called Machado out but did not call Trumbo out as the rule would have required them to do if it was an illegal slide.  The MLB rules, in the section, entitled “sliding to bases on double play attempts” defines what constitutes a legal or, as the rule calls it, a “bona fide” slide.  

Advertisement

The rule is very clear and states “A runner who engages in a ‘bona fide slide’ shall not be called out for interference under this Rule 7.14. even in cases where the runner makes contact with the fielder as a consequence of a permissible slide.” The four conditions which make a slide a “bona fide slide” are; (1) The runner’ begins his slide (i.e., makes contact with the ground) before reaching the base; (2) The runner “is able and attempts to reach the base with his hand or foot”; (3) The runner “is able and attempts to remain on the base after completion of the slide”; and (4) slides within reach of the base without changing his pathway for the purpose of initiating contact with a fielder.

Machado definitely began his slide before the base, he reached the base with his foot, hand and back side. In fact, when he completed his slide he was almost sitting on the base, and aside from the fact that he lost contact with the bag when he reached up to help the falling Pedroia, he maintained contact with the base. He slid in directly to the base without changing his direction for any reason.

The slide complied with the rules in every aspect and the rule, even though it is poorly conceived and applied, even anticipates that a runner will occasionally contact a fielder with a “bona fide” slide when it exempts a runner from a penalty for that contact if the slide is “bona fide.”

The rule, which was adopted as a knee jerk reaction to Chase Utley’s slide that broke Ruben Tejada’s leg in the playoffs in 2015, was intended to protect fielders from injury in cases of take out slides in double play situations. It has resulted in some unintended consequences, one of which is that it has lulled middle infielders into thinking that they are not in danger when making the pivot on a double play.  Anyone who heard Pedroia’s reaction to the contact would realize that even he felt like it was no big deal.

The Red Sox were understandably upset that their leader and most productive player had been injured and some members of the media were quick to condemn Machado and add fuel to the fire. Dave O’Brien and Jerry Remy, of the NESN television crew, handled the incident objectively and professionally but the daytime talk shows, and their less than objective callers, had a field day, condemning Machado for the slide and Pedroia for his honesty.  

The fact that the principals in the incident, Pedroia and Machado, are their teams’ leaders added fuel to the fire. If Marco Hernandez were playing second and was slid into by Ryan Flaherty, the slide would probably have gone relatively unnoticed after the umpires issued their ruling. Given who it was, there was bound to be retribution from the Sox and, anyone who knows baseball would have no problem with Machado being hit in the leg with a pitch.

Advertisement

Barnes may have intended to hit Machado in the leg but he didn’t. There is never a reason to throw at a batter’s head. Throwing near his head in this situation is inexcusable. Like it or not, the Red Sox were wrong in this part of the situation.    

The incident was poorly handled by almost everyone except Pedroia and Machado. Pedroia dealt with the slide professionally, accepting his responsibility to protect himself.  Machado made a legal slide and dealt with the “beaning” professionally.  Regardless of what the talk show “experts” had to say, Pedroia and Machado having it out face to face on the field was an effective end to any problems between them.  

The Red Sox and Orioles meet tomorrow in the first game of a four game series in Fenway. These two teams could come down to the last game of the season in a battle for the Eastern Division.  It’s early in the season for a critical series but these next four days are as close as it gets.

The young Red Sox players do not need to get caught up in a vendetta against the Orioles that interferes with and detracts from the task at hand, winning the American League East on the way to the World Series.  Manager John Farrell has the responsibility to put this incident behind his players and ensure they are focused on that goal.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.