WELLS — Typically in sports, there are two types of rivalries: Those built on competition, and those built on the convenience of geography.
For years, Wells had the best of both, with its fiercest rivals ”“ York and Kennebunk ”“ coming from neighboring towns.
But since last year, when the reclassification of high school football made Wells the only team from York County in Western Class C and the majority of teams at least an hour’s trip away, the Warriors have been forced to find that other kind of rival ”“ one whose foundations would be laid on the field.
Enter into the equation Spruce Mountain, a program created in 2011 when Jay and Livermore Falls High Schools were consolidated into one. After early struggles, the Phoenix have turned into one of the best teams in Western Class C the past few seasons, joining Wells, Cape Elizabeth, Leavitt and Yarmouth at the proverbial big boys table in the conference.
Wells and Spruce Mountain will write another chapter in the book of their budding rivalry Friday night when the third-seeded Warriors (7-2) travel to Griffin Field in Jay for a regional semifinal against the second-seeded Phoenix (8-1).
Wells beat Spruce Mountain by a combined 98-0 when the teams met the first two times in 2011 and 2012. But the Phoenix showed they had risen last fall, beating higher-seeded Wells 29-20 in the regional semis and following it up with a 27-6 victory over the Warriors during the regular season this year, earning Wells’ respect in the process.
“I feel like Spruce has gotten a lot better over the years,” Wells senior Chris Carney said. “Even back in my sophomore year, people were saying this is going to be a big rivalry game. I definitely think in years to come this is going to be a rivalry from the reputation they’ve built and we’ve built.”
“It’s definitely not a natural rivalry in terms of where we live,” added Wells coach Tim Roche. “But we had always said as coaches, we knew that Jay and Livermore had good football. It took them a couple of years to figure things out when they came together, and they’ve just gotten better and better. They’re a good program and I love the way they play.”
That 27-6 final score from earlier this year was slightly misleading. Wells dominated the first half, gaining 209 yards to Spruce Mountain’s 88, only to trail 7-6 at halftime as the Warriors failed to finish off several drives due to costly mistakes.
“It was penalties and it was drives needing to be finished,” Carney said. “We were pounding it and pounding it and just couldn’t finish. The motto since has been finish ”“ finish drives, finish plays, finish games. You’ve only got so many chances, and you’ve got to capitalize when you get there.”
The Wells defense was also able to control the Phoenix’ offense until the third quarter, when Spruce Mountain standout running back Matt Vigue finally broke touchdown runs of 43 and 53 yards, adding a 65-yarder in the fourth quarter to seal the game.
“Defensively, we stuffed them for almost all the first half,” Wells linebacker Ryan Marsh said. “But they had three or four big plays and it got us. They have a great offense.”
Containing the shifty Vigue, quarterback Peter Theriault and the rest of Spruce Mountain’s big-play option attack that is averaging 43.2 points per game this season will be a challenge for Wells.
“They have a bunch of athletes. True athletes,” Carney said. “(Theriault) is good, Matt Vigue is good, they’ve got good wide receivers. They’re a very finesse team and they get it done. They’re one of those teams where if you make a mistake defensively, they’re going to capitalize offensively. You’ve got to be perfect with everything you do.”
That “perfect” includes not allowing the Phoenix to break off those big plays that decided the first game and getting off the field defensively on third down, said Marsh.
“You’ve got to play on your toes,” Marsh said. “In the first Spruce game, a couple of us linebackers would make a crucial mistake ”“ we’d step the wrong way and be out of the play ”“ and those are mistakes we’ve corrected and need to execute.”
The Wells offense has found its groove as well, and coincidentally, is also averaging 43.2 points per game since that loss at Spruce Mountain on Sept. 12, including 55 in a 27-point win against Poland in the playoff opener last Friday.
A big part of that has been Carney, who has run for more than 1,700 yards and scored 28 touchdowns ”“ both school records ”“ behind an offensive line that has developed into a strong unit as the fall has worn on.
Michael Curtis ”“ a lineman turned fullback this season ”“ has also emerged into a 230-pound load to tackle, especially in big games. Curtis ran for 145 yards against Yarmouth, 119 against Cape Elizabeth and 104 against Leavitt, while also scoring on runs of 45 and 10 yards against Poland last week.
It will be those two ball carriers, as well as the arm of quarterback Nate Booth, that will have to carry the bulk of the load offensively for the Warriors, who gained more than 400 yards rushing in the first game against Phoenix despite scoring only six points.
That loss, along with a 26-19 defeat to Leavitt in a game that Wells at one point led 19-0, has the Warriors seeking redemption as the playoffs start to hit the boiling point this week.
“We messed up and lost two games that we shouldn’t have,” Marsh said. “Those two games I really think were fluke games. We messed up and did some stupid things at stupid times, and they came out with higher numbers than we did. But we know we’re one of the better teams in the conference and can play with them.
“We don’t see it as we’re the underdog. We’re going to come out firing because we know it’s one and done. You mess up this week and you’re done.”
The winner of the Wells-Spruce Mountain game will play the winner of Friday night’s other semifinal between No. 5 Yarmouth (6-3) and top-seeded Leavitt (8-1) in the regional final.
Yarmouth, Wells and Leavitt have all won at least one state championship in the last three years, while Spruce Mountain’s emergence means the Phoenix aren’t likely far away from raising a Gold Ball as well, a rise that Wells hopes to halt on Friday night.
“You’ve got four teams left and any one of the four teams can win it,” Roche said. “I really believe that. I don’t think there’s a clear-cut favorite. It’s a good class of football because every team has to compete this week; there’s no cakewalk in the final four.”
— Staff Writer Cameron Dunbar can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 323 or cdunbar@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less