4 min read

I’d like to say that last Wednesday’s decision by the Maine Principals’ Association to deny Biddeford’s football team a waiver to play the next two seasons in Class B rather than Class A came as a surprise.

But, of course, it didn’t. This is the MPA after all, and allowing the Tigers to play in Class B ”“ where their enrollment, under rules set by the MPA itself, says they should play ”“ just made too much sense.

I’d like to say that the MPA had some sort of reason, a good reason, for this decision, but I can’t, because no one knows their actual reasoning. Their Interscholastic Management Committee heard the case, went into executive session and then denied the waiver in a vote that lasted about a minute; a summary denial of a year’s worth of work put together by Biddeford administrators and coaches with zero explanation given.

I’d like to say fans at this past Saturday’s state championship football games in Portland ”“ fans who love high school football and the schools they support, as evidenced by the fact they were willing to spend hours outside in the freezing cold ”“ were allowed to freely go in and out of Fitzpatrick Stadium as they pleased.

They did, after all, pay $8 for a ticket to get in ”“ if they want to leave for a short period to warm up, or get a bite to eat, they should have that right and be able to reenter with the original ticket stub. But of course, the MPA says that once you leave, you must pay to get back in, a cynical way of getting these fans to buy the concession-stand coffee and burgers.

Advertisement

There’s a lot of people I meet as a sports journalist in Southern Maine who would like to say a lot about the MPA, and do so in private. I have the privilege of being able to say those things publicly in these pages. So far, I’ve declined to do so; the MPA is an easy target, after all, a punching bag, so why belabor the point?

But the Biddeford football decision is something that can’t and shouldn’t be allowed to pass quietly into the annals of history.

To be sure, the people at Biddeford put themselves in this position. By petitioning to play up a class above where it’s enrollment says it should be, the Tigers committed to four years of playing Class A football ”“ although many in Biddeford thought that commitment was for just two years, something the MPA probably should have made sure to communicate in the clearest possible terms beforehand.

Now, Biddeford is trying to get out of that commitment after just two years. Quite simply, they made a mistake, and as Biddeford Athletic Director Dennis Walton says, they “own it.” But the football program, and most importantly the school’s football players, shouldn’t be forced to pay for it any longer.

The MPA’s own Football Committee, made up of people with football backgrounds, agreed and subsequently passed Biddeford’s waiver request unanimously in October. But the Interscholastic Management Committee, the group with final say that is made up of eight school administrators from around the state ”“ four of whom come from schools that don’t even have football programs ”“ denied the request.

What’s their reasoning behind the denial? We don’t know, and we likely never will, because the MPA ”“ like a legislative body in some Banana republic ”“ doesn’t have to explain their reasoning.

Advertisement

More than likely they’ll hide behind the four-year rule, which actually does permit waivers of the kind Biddeford was requesting. Apparently there was no leeway, and by all indications this committee proved incapable of looking at each individual case on its merits; perhaps, it was just amusing to watch Biddeford jumping through all these hoops for nothing.

Even if the MPA felt like it owed Biddeford an explanation for the no vote, it would be hard to credibly deliver. The Tigers are, after all, simply trying to move back down to the class of football that the MPA itself says they should be in. The MPA claims time and time again that a level playing field, based off the size of a school’s enrollment, is a top priority in all sports.

That was their main reasoning behind switching Maine from a three-class to a four-class system two years ago in the first place ”“ to ensure more competitive balance, something they threw out the window because in this case, it was convenient for them to do so.

As someone who has been connected to the Biddeford football program for decades told me after just hours after the decision came down to deny the waiver request, “The MPA claims to care about a level playing field. The MPA could care less about a level playing field.”

Based on last Wednesday’s events, who could disagree?

When it comes down to it, whether or not Biddeford’s football team plays in Class A or Class B the next two falls doesn’t amount to a hill of beans for most people in this state. Undoubtedly there are plenty of people ”“ many of them still stuck in the glory days of 1980s and 90s ”“ in Biddeford itself who are happy that the Tigers will play two more years in Class A.

But in the end, this does matter. Because even though in the end this one decision really only affects Biddeford, it’s symptomatic of a much larger and flawed way of thinking that pervades through the Maine Principals’ Association. And as the governing body for high school sports competitions in this state, the decisions of that organization end up affecting everyone.

— Staff Writer Cameron Dunbar can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 323 or cdunbar@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.