The income gap between the rich and
everybody else is behind the growth of populism in the U.S. and
Europe, according to new political analyses.
On one side are the rich and on the
other is the middle class. The poor rarely are mentioned these days,
either because it is disgraceful to be poor or because government
wants to cut back on helping them.
Deep political divisions are likely to
be about money. Many among the rich want to keep it and get more,
while everybody else treads water or falls behind. Some who are
losing out have become populists, seeking political power in hopes of
boosting their incomes.
Here’s an example. Unemployed coal
miners support President Trump’s push to revive coal mining. It’s
all about recovering jobs for miners who have lost theirs to
competing resources. It’s certainly not about anybody’s
preference for coal.
Complicating the split is the fact that
many people who say they are in the middle class aren’t. “Stop
pretending You’re Not Rich” was the title of a recent commentary
by Richard Reeves in the New York Times.
Reeves grew up in class-conscious
Britain but discovered classes were more firmly established in the
U.S. than there. In Britain, the upper economic class flaunts their
status, while in the U.S., the rich are in denial.
The wealthy are not only the now-famous
top one percent who own more of the economy than the bottom 90
percent. Some high-income people who consider themselves members of
the middle class are rich. They may join in blaming the superrich
for income inequality, but they have gained more than the much
larger, true middle class.
The rich are a self-renewing group.
While the American myth is that people succeed based on merit, the
rich pass on their privileged opportunity to their children. There’s
nothing wrong with that, but it tends to create an upper class. They
can gain access to housing and the best schools. And they can
benefit from special tax breaks.
Writing in London’s Financial Times,
Edward Luce carries the theme further. Somewhat surprisingly, he
noted, “France has done a better job at keeping its left-behinds
above water than its Anglo-Saxon rivals (U.S. and Britain).”
Working age males are more likely to
find jobs in France than in the U.S. And the income gap is smaller
there.
Luce’s key point is that not only do
the U.S. and the U.K. have a market economy, but they also have a
“market society.” We may consider that system promotes
“individual freedom,” but it means people must fend for
themselves. Some of the wealthy, while opposing big government, have
designed it to favor their pocketbooks.
This split has spurred many of the less
privileged to turn to movements promising change and the kind of
policies they want. For example, they believe immigrants take good
jobs, not merely entry-level positions, away from them and want it
stopped.
Trump’s surprise electoral victory
seemed to send the message that the ignored middle-class was on the
path to power and control. The simple idea that Trump would bring
change was enough to help him to win.
In Britain, anti-immigration voting led
to Brexit, designed to stop immigrants from Eastern Europe. In the
Netherlands and France, populists threatened to win the national
elections, but failed. The tough British Conservative Party position
on Brexit and government spending cost it a parliamentary majority.
Populism has tapped into a belief that
government overreaches. In response, the president and the GOP
Congress kill Obama’s rules on the environment and consumer
protection. But Trump struggles as he finds keeping political
promises is much harder than making them, even with his party
controlling Congress.
In the Washington Post, Ishaan Tharoor
writes that “right-wing populists” are now in retreat. They have
created chaos, the columnist says, which is leading to a revival of
interest in government action on the economy, aimed at reducing
inequality.
In the Netherlands, France, Britain and
Germany, right-wing populism has been halted or pushed back. Nowhere
has it brought back the middle class, economically or politically.
Meanwhile, social democrats like Bernie
Sanders in the U.S. and Jeremy Corbyn in the U.K. have been expanding
participation. Recently, increased support for Democratic in
normally solid Republican congressional districts has raised doubts
about the much-heralded populist message of the 2016 elections.
The experiment with a “market
society,” with as little government as possible, is not producing
the promised result of greater prosperity for all. Will the
political reaction against right-wing populism taking place in Europe
reach America’s shores?
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less