BIDDEFORD — The City Council voted 5-4 Tuesday to table a project that would address safety concerns at Biddeford Municipal Airport.
Councilor Bradley Cote proposed the motion to table, which was seconded by Councilor Clement Fleurent. Additionally, Councilors Robert Quattrone, Roger Hurtubise and Marc Lessard voted in favor of it, while Council President John McCurry along with Councilors Michael Swanton, Bob Mills and Michael Ready voted against it.
As it stands, the project requires the city to accept federal and state grants in the amounts of $866,250 and $48,125, respectively, and to contribute $48,125 of its own funds to address safety concerns at the airport.
Trees close to the runway have grown taller than what the Federal Aviation Administration considers safe, and they must be trimmed or removed to bring the airport up to code. But before the trees can be cut, the city must obtain land currently owned by the New England Electric Railway Historical Society, which is where many of the trees are.
Prior to the vote, residents of neighborhoods close to the airport spoke out in favor of preserving the trees that sit on or near their properties.
“My trees are part of my landscape,” said Mark Tardif. “It’s not like I have 10 acres of woods, and a little clear-cutting wouldn’t be noticed. I have beautiful, old oak trees that create shade and keep my house cool in the summer.”
Another resident said he and others who live near the airport worry that the city will move in without notice, armed with disruptive, property-damaging construction equipment. He pondered what “removing vegetative obstructions” actually means; does it mean tree topping or cutting trees down to their stumps?
Airport Commission Chair Rick Laverriere later addressed that question.
“As far as lopping trees down to the stumps”¦ that’s not the plan,” he said. “The plan is to top them. It’s just for the airplanes to come in.”
Mark Tardif’s father, Ray Tardif, voiced graver concerns over the project, alleging that it would allow for airport expansion, despite the fact that expansion is not written into any of the plans.
“When the Airport Commission proposes land acquisition rather than obtaining easements to remove trees that interfere with the flight path, that tells me that there is more going on than cutting trees,” he said.
Laverriere staunchly denied Tardif’s theory.
“As long as I’m chair (of the Airport Commission), I will not address anything about expansion,” he said. “I don’t know anything about expansion, nor do I think we’ll ever be approved for expansion. If there are plans, I don’t know about them, and I’m a man who speaks the truth.”
Resident Richard Rhames said that purchasing an easement versus buying the land would be “more than enough” to allow for the tree removal, but he also recognized the fact that the historical society is against that solution and wants the city to purchase its property outright.
Rhames went on to say that the project is a means of increasing airport operations, and that’s something that won’t sit well with residents of that area.
“This is to facilitate nighttime operation, which, needless to say, is going to be relatively obnoxious to people who live up there,” he said. “The whole point is to facilitate more traffic at the airport.”
When Councilor Cote proposed tabling the project, he laid out the argument he’s made several times at meetings past: More data on the airport needs to be collected before an “educated decision” can be made in terms of spending money on it.
“I’ve been asking the same questions for three years, just trying to get basic data on the airport. ”¦ The reason I’m tabling is I can’t see putting any more money toward the airport until we have all the data,” he said.
Fred Oliver, a member of the Airport Commission, said he thinks the city doesn’t realize the economic possibilities of the airport because it hasn’t been using it the right way.
“You’re not utilizing the airport the way I believe you should,” said Oliver. “The airport can be an asset as far as marketing this community. ”¦ There’s a pilot at the airport that flies banners every summer over our beaches, but I’ve never seen a banner saying, ”˜Come visit downtown Biddeford.’”
Council President McCurry said he was “really disappointed” in the result of Tuesday’s meeting. He alluded to the 2008 referendum in which more than 80 percent of voters chose to keep the airport open; therefore, it’s the city’s responsibility to keep it safe, he argued.
“We’ve had a referendum,” said McCurry. “We’ve got to maintain this thing.”
Mayor Alan Casavant shared a similar sentiment.
“When you keep something open, you have to maintain it ”“ maintain its safety,” he said.
— Staff Writer Angelo J. Verzoni can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 329 or averzoni@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less