BIDDEFORD — James Pak, the Biddeford landlord accused of murdering two teenagers in 2012, had a “mini stroke” approximately five months prior to the killings, and he also has symptoms consistent with some degree of dementia, according to witness testimonies presented in court Thursday.
Psychologist Kerry Drach, who works for the State Forensic Service, conducted two pyschological examinations of Pak in 2013 ”“ one at Riverview Psychiatric Center in Augusta and another at the York County Jail in Alfred. Drach was the first of two witnesses to testify at a hearing to determine Pak’s mental competency to stand trial in York County Superior Court in Alfred Thursday.
On the stand, Drach said that Pak told him he was concerned over short-term memory loss he had been suffering since a July 2012 stroke.
Drach said he also spoke with Pak’s wife, Armit Pak, who told him she was concerned less with her husband’s memory loss and more with his increasingly ill temper following the stroke.
“She said that she had noticed changes in his behavior after the stroke. … Since the stroke he had had temper outbursts more frequently,” said Drach.
Robert Riley, a neuropsychologist who also does work in forensic psychology, was the second witness to testify Thursday, and explained that the stroke Drach referenced is what’s known as a transient ischemic attack, or TIA ”“ often referred to as a “mini stroke.”
Riley conducted two psychological examinations of Pak, as well ”“ both at Riverview in 2014.
Drach also noted in his reports that Pak at times struggles with the English language, suffers from short-term memory loss, and has some level of cognitive impairment and even tendencies to suggest “moderate dementia.”
“(Pak) obtained a score that was definitely considered in the range of some degree of dementia,” he said about one of the tests he administered.
But at Thursday’s hearing, Drach backed down from his original claim regarding dementia, calling it a “mistake,” and explaining that the tests he conducted are strictly used as screening tools for the disease, and they can’t be used to diagnose it.
Riley, on the other hand, said he made very few observations consistent with a dementia diagnosis.
“There needs to be a decline in both cognitive ability as well as functional ability to make a diagnosis of dementia,” said Riley, and he never observed that in Pak. He said that in hospital records he reviewed, doctors, nurses and other staff even reported that Pak was able to socialize, play cards and read during his stay at Riverview.
Both men did agreed that Pak displayed a tendency to “perseverate,” as Drach put it, on the incident that led to his incarceration, repeatedly claiming it wasn’t his fault.
“He tended to speak negatively about the victims of the crime and about how it was all their fault,” said Drach.
The incident took place on Dec. 29, 2012, when Pak allegedly shot and killed Derrick Thompson, 19, and Alivia Welch, 18, over a parking dispute. He also allegedly shot Thompson’s mother, Susan Johnson, who survived.
Pak has been charged with two counts of murder, one count of aggravated attempted murder and burglary. In 2013, he pleaded not guilty to all charges by reason of insanity.
Since a defendant’s competency is largely determined by his or her ability to assist the defense, Pak’s understanding of the judicial system was another much-discussed topic at Thursday’s hearing.
Drach said Pak demonstrated to him a loose understanding of the judicial system; for example, he knew that his lawyer was there to “help him” and that the judge was there to make a ruling on the case.
But Joel Vincent, one of Pak’s two attorneys, said this speaks little about his client’s ability to assist in the defense of a criminal trial. Vincent compared Pak’s understanding of the judicial system to “merely knowing how to arrange the checkers on a checker board,” without necessarily knowing how to play the game.
Drach acknowledged this point, and when asked if he thought Pak would be “significantly challenged” in working with his attorneys, he said, “That was my feeling.”
But as Assistant Attorney General Deborah Cashman questioned him, Drach made it clear that he thought Pak wasn’t so cognitively deficient that he couldn’t be educated about the court process.
Ultimately, however, Drach said he didn’t feel confident going one way or the other on the question of Pak’s competency to stand trial.
Riley, on the other hand, said, “I believe he does have the requisite skills,” when asked by the state whether he thinks Pak is competent to stand trial.
But in his cross examination of Riley, Lawrence Goodglass, Pak’s second attorney, took issue with the psychologist’s methods, arguing that anytime Pak performed poorly on one of his tests, Riley tended to chalk that up to a lack of effort versus true cognitive impairment.
Goodglass also said Riley’s examinations don’t accurately represent Pak’s cognitive ability in a courtroom, as they were conducted in the “less stressful” environment of a psychiatric facility.
Riley fired back, though, explaining that psychological examinations are meant to be conducted in a quiet, low-stress environment, as to prevent results skewed by non-psychological factors.
Drach and Riley were called to testify by the state Thursday. Riley didn’t get the chance to complete his testimony due to time limitations. But he will have a chance to finish ”“ and the defense will also have a chance to call its own witnesses to the stand ”“ before Justice John O’Neil Jr. makes a decision regarding Pak’s competency to stand trial.
The hearing is expected to resume this spring.
— Staff Writer Angelo J. Verzoni can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 329 or averzoni@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less