4 min read

Within the next few days, Mainers who haven’t already done so will be filing their state and federal income tax returns. It’s safe to say that federal returns usually look a lot better than state returns. Most W-2 employees are breaking even or seeing a big refund from the feds, but often using it to cover underpayments to the state.

Imagine that dynamic changing the next time you file your taxes, and you may be more likely to keep an open mind about Gov. Paul LePage’s tax reform proposal.

Maine’s income tax is grossly uncompetitive with that of other states. Our top rate, at 7.95 percent, is the ninth highest in the country. But our problem isn’t just that our top rate is so high, it’s that nearly everybody is paying it. An individual filer in Maine enters that highest tax bracket after their first $20,900 in income.

The eight states with higher top rates than ours don’t start levying them until taxpayers reach $1 million in income (California), $200,000 (Hawaii), $68,000 (Iowa), $152,540 (Minnesota), $500,000 (New Jersey), $1,029,000 (New York), $125,000 (Oregon), or $405,100 (Vermont).

Again, Maine’s highest rate starts at just $20,900. For all intents and purposes, Maine has the most onerous income tax in the nation. Some complain about implementing tax cuts for the rich, but the truth is, we’ve been taxing everybody like they were rich.

Advertisement

As Senate chairwoman of the business committee in the state legislature and, more importantly, a member of a business-owning family myself, I can tell you firsthand that Maine’s outlier income tax is a massive deterrent to economic development and job creation in our state. The high overhead it creates puts Maine businesses, most of which file using personal income tax rates, at a disadvantage when trying to keep up with competitors in other states. It also makes it more difficult to recruit skilled employees. Workers get an automatic eight percent raise when they take a job offer in New Hampshire.

Since 1969, when the state income tax was created in Maine, the economy has seen considerable changes.

First, Maine’s economy is increasingly reliant on tourism. With a large share of spending in our state coming from visitors, it makes sense to focus our taxation on consumption rather than income. Maine has one of the lowest sales tax rates in the country and that just doesn’t make sense for a state with a large seasonal population that pays no income tax.

Second, people today are more mobile than they were in 1969. Workers, especially younger ones, change jobs and careers often. There is more of a need today for states to offer competitive costs of living, a large part of which is derived from the income tax.

It’s true, there are many factors holding back our economy that are beyond our control: our remote geography, aging demographic, and harsh winters. But there are a handful of things we can do to make Maine competitive. Reforming our tax code is one of them.

This is low-hanging fruit. All it takes is a couple of votes in the legislature and the swipe of the Governor’s pen, and we can make Maine’s economy just a little bit stronger virtually overnight.

Advertisement

In 2013, I was part of the legislature’s informal “Gang of 11”—five Democrats, five Republicans, and an Independent who put forward a plan to reduce Maine’s income and property taxes in exchange for a slightly higher and broadened sales tax.

I see many of the same elements in Governor Paul LePage’s tax reform plan currently before the legislature. It would reduce our top income tax rate from 7.95 to 5.75 percent, cut taxes on pensions, eliminate the death tax, and provide property tax relief not to towns but directly to taxpayers. It would help cover some of this revenue loss by eliminating special exemptions in the sales tax code and raising the rate modestly from 5.5 to 6.5 percent, leaving a total net tax cut of $300 million when all is said and done.

Maine Democrats showed with their 2009 plan that they see the economic value in reducing our state income tax, and certainly Republicans want to lower our overall tax burden.

This plan accomplishes the broad goals of both parties. Like most bills, it likely won’t pass exactly as proposed. But if we conclude the 2015 legislative session without reducing Maine’s income taxes, all Maine citizens and lawmakers should consider it a major disappointment. Maine can do better, and with bold action in Augusta, we will.

— State Sen. Amy Volk (R-Scarborough) is Senate Chair of the Legislature’s Labor, Commerce, Research & Economic Development Committee. She also serves on the State Workforce Investment Board and the Citizen Trade Policy Commission.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.