5 min read

ALFRED — York County Judge of Probate Robert M.A. Nadeau, who is facing five alleged violations of the judicial code of conduct, may learn next month the findings of a Maine Supreme Judicial Court justice who heard the case earlier this year.

Nadeau appeared before Active Retired Maine Supreme Court Justice Robert W. Clifford at a testimonial hearing at Androscoggin County Superior Court in Auburn Feb. 23. Clifford will make a recommended finding of fact to the full Maine Supreme Judicial Court sometime in May, after memos from both sides are due. The court will later render a decision.

The examination follows a fact-finding probe by the Maine Judicial Responsibility and Disability Committee, which alleges that Nadeau violated a number of judicial canons that speak to integrity and decorum.

Nadeau served as the county’s probate judge from about 1997 to 2008. He lost the 2008 election, but was elected again in November 2012 for a four-year term that began in January 2013. In Maine, probate judges work part-time and some, like Nadeau, maintain private law practices. Probate judges are the only elected judges in Maine.

Nadeau previously ran afoul of the Judicial Code of Conduct in 2007, following a complaint by the judicial responsibility committee. At that time Nadeau, in his capacity as a judge, was censured by the Maine Supreme Judicial Court and ordered suspended for 30 days for misrepresentations he made concerning his opponent in his 2004 pre-primary election advertising.

Advertisement

The new charges emerged late in 2012, following a letter of complaint to the Maine Judicial Responsibility and Disability Committee by attorney Gene Libby and five other attorneys who have not been named in court filings.

Specifically, the judicial committee alleged Nadeau violated the judicial canon that spells out that judges “shall not lend the prestige of judicial office to advance the private interests of the judge” by maintaining a judicial website that contained a link to his law practice website.

The committee also alleged that by maintaining a Facebook page that stated it was the “Official Page of York County Probate Judge Robert Nadeau,” he violated judicial canons that spell out that judges “shall act at all times in a manner that promotes public confidence in the integrity and impartiality of the judiciary,” as well as a canon that speaks to conducting extra-judicial activities in a manner so as not to “demean the judicial office.”

The committee further alleged Nadeau, in a letter to attorney Tyler Smith, who was representing a woman against whom Nadeau had filed a harassment complaint at York District Court, had threatened consequences if the litigation was not settled. The letter allegedly referenced his judicial office, violating judicial canons.

As well, the judicial committee charged Nadeau allegedly violated standards of judicial conduct that speak to the integrity and independence of the judiciary in connection with a remark he made about the district court judge who handled his harassment complaint, alleging the judge was “very female- biased and unknowing.”

The committee also charged that Nadeau allegedly used information he acquired for a purpose unrelated to his judicial duties when he cited an email message in which attorney Libby had referred to Nadeau as “His Eminence.” According to documents prepared by the judicial committee, the email was obtained by Nadeau through his official capacity as a judge.

Advertisement

In a transcript of the Feb. 23 hearing before Justice Clifford, Nadeau said that the judicial website, created by a third party on his behalf following his 2012 election campaign, did at one time link to his private law practice. He said once he learned there was an issue, it was taken down. He said the Facebook page, created initially as part of his election campaign, had also been taken down. Nadeau said his creation of the “Official Page of York County Probate Judge Robert Nadeau” Facebook page simply reflected that it was his, and not an official county Facebook page.

“If I caused that impression to be created in anybody’s mind, I apologize,” Nadeau said, according to the transcript.

His attorney, Stephen Wade, in a telephone interview Wednesday, said the Facebook page contained photos of Nadeau’s children and would not have been mistaken for an official page of the county government. According to the judicial committee, the page also contained photos of York County Court House and Nadeau in his judicial robes.

Wade pointed out the Maine Judicial Responsibility and Disability Committee does not have a member who is a probate judge ”“ Maine’s only judges who must campaign for elected office, and said that because the state’s other judges are appointed, the sort of public interaction that goes on with an elected official doesn’t happen.

Wade also pointed out that the complaint about Nadeau’s website and Facebook page was made in December 2012, after he was elected, but before he had taken office and had he known there was an issue, he could have had the pages removed sooner.

The letter Nadeau wrote to attorney Smith, who works for Libby’s law firm, contains the sentence, “but absent immediate, legitimate responsibility and cooperation designed to achieve an amicable nonmonetary remedy of whatever issues your client and I apparently have, I respectfully submit that this is going to become very bad for you ”“ for your client, for you and for your law firm.” A footnote in Nadeau’s letter to Smith referred to Libby’s reference to him as “His Eminence.” Nadeau wrote that if the moniker “was not meant to be pejorative or disrespectful of him as a jurist,” he expected a full explanation from Libby within 10 days.

Advertisement

Nadeau, according to the transcript, said that it was not his intention to threaten anybody. And as to the “His Eminence” reference, he said in retrospect he should have written Libby separately.

As to the remark Nadeau made about the York District Court judge, Wade said Nadeau was speaking in his capacity as a lawyer, not as a judge.

The Committee on Judicial Responsibility and Disability began investigating the allegations in late December 2012, when Libby and the other lawyers wrote a letter of complaint regarding the judicial website and Facebook page. Then, on March 26, 2013, another complaint was received from Libby concerning Nadeau and his alleged conduct regarding Smith, who was representing Lynnann Frydrych in the harassment complaint. Frydrych had once had a relationship with Nadeau ”“ they had been engaged at one point ”“ and she later co-authored a book entitled “The Ethics of Judge Nadeau.”

As well as his prior censure, Nadeau was also the subject of two reprimands issued by Justice Donald Alexander of the Maine Supreme Judicial Court in 2006 in connection with his conduct in his private practice. A third count was dismissed with a warning. Those complaints were brought by the Maine Board of Overseers of the Bar.

— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.