4 min read

The Portland Press Herald published an editorial on April 8, which stated that “for over 100 years, state law has allowed ordinary Mainers to put policy questions to voters at the ballot box through petition drives. The citizen initiative process is a cornerstone of participatory democracy here.”

The Bangor Daily News published an editorial on April 9, which stated that “taking away the citizen initiative when it comes to hunting and fishing laws, or any other area of law, is wrong.”

Neither of these major newspapers is anti-hunting; in fact, both of them came out against a ballot initiative in November 2014 to ban the baiting, hounding and trapping of bears in Maine. Four constitutional amendments banning hunting-related citizen initiatives are now being proposed. One has to wonder about the constitutionality of these proposals to amend the Maine State Constitution. These bills would take away Mainers’ longstanding constitutional right to vote on wildlife issues and would prevent wildlife issues from being placed on the ballot. They are as follows:

LD 754: Proposing an Amendment to the Constitution of Maine to Ensure That Laws Governing Hunting and Fishing Are Not Subject to the Citizen Petition Process. Sponsored by Rep. Stephen Wood (R-Greene). Referred to the Veterans and Legal Affairs Committee.

LD 1084: Proposing an Amendment to the Constitution of Maine to Exclude Wildlife Issues from Citizen Initiatives. Sponsored by Rep. Michelle Dunphy (D-Old Town). Referred to the Veterans and Legal Affairs Committee.

Advertisement

LD 703: Proposing an Amendment to the Constitution of Maine to Protect the People’s Right to Hunt, Fish and Harvest Wildlife. Sponsored by Rep. Karleton Ward (R-Dedham). Referred to the Inland Fisheries and Wildlife Committee.

LD 753: Proposing an Amendment to the Constitution of Maine to Establish the Right to Hunt and Fish. Sponsored by Rep. Stephen Wood (R-Greene). Referred to the Inland Fisheries and Wildlife Committee.

Animal rights organization and wildlife protection groups claim that Maine’s powerful hunting lobby is desperately trying to abolish the citizen initiative process because the National Humane Society is contemplating putting a measure on the ballet that would ban the hounding and trapping of bears in 2016. The Inland Fisheries and Wildlife Committee has 14 members, of whom at least eight and possibly more are reportedly either members of the Sportsman’s Alliance of Maine, or have been highly rated by SAM for their support or both. The four proposed amendments to the constitution would ensure that laws governing hunting and fishing are not subject to the citizen petition process.

Forget about the issue, which in this case, is hunting. It could be anything: same-sex marriage, gambling, medical cannabis, the legalization of marijuana for recreational use, and environmental issues, such as tar-sands oil and windmills, which could be exempted from citizen review. Passage of any one of these bills would set a dangerous precedent and effectively lessen the ability to fight for wildlife and other issues in this state. Lawmakers should reject these bills as an effort to weaken the public’s right to directly influence the political process.

To many people, these proposed four amendments probably sound like a solution in search of a problem. The hunting lobby in Augusta claims that the 47.7 percent of the electorate who voted yes in last year’s failed bear referendum were manipulated by the National Humane Society; yet the National Rifle Association and other pro-hunting groups around the country regularly contribute money and influence to the legislative process in Maine and other states.

Backers of these amendments believe that issues involving wildlife are too complicated to be understood by the average voter. Restrictions on the citizen initiative process are being considered right now and may be brought forth in one or more proposed bills during this current 127th legislature session.

Advertisement

Legislators accept money from the big national gun lobbies to push the radical agenda of well-funded, outside lobbyists through Maine legislative committees. Some of these committee members also have vested interests in selling more guns, traps, and licenses to even younger children as a recent bill, LD 156, proposes to lower the hunting age of children from age 10 to eight years old.

The NRA-ILA (the Institute for Legislative Action, the lobbying arm of the National Rifle Association) is attempting to preemptively protect hunters and gun owners from “radical” animal rights groups by warning voters and state legislators across this state and around the country that the National Humane Society is coming for their guns and fishing rods. HSUS says that it has no plans to go after hunting and fishing rights and has called these amendments inconsequential and merely window dressing saying that hunting and fishing should remain a privilege, not a right written into the constitution.

— Val Philbrick works in the production department of the Journal Tribune as a pre-press person. She is a member of PETA and the Humane Society of the United States.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.