3 min read

ARUNDEL — Looks like the town of Arundel will be heading to court regarding disagreements with Dubois Livestock over permitting the company’s composting facility once again.

Just last year, the two had reached an agreement that was supposed to resolve all legal conflicts between them. Justice John O’Neil issued a consent decree on June 27, 2016, that was to provide a way to move forward.

However, Arundel and Dubois disagree over the meaning of language in the consent decree, and the town Planning Board did not grant the company a permit renewal for its composting facility, claiming that it didn’t fulfill requirements of the decree.

For it’s part Dubois board of director Sal Fedder said during a Planning Board meeting on Aug. 10, the company met its requirements and that the Planning Board didn’t have the authority to deny the permit.

On Monday, the Board of Selectmen decided to instruct the town code enforcement officer to issue a notice of violation against Dubois. After that, “we’ll probably be in court to resolve” the issue, Town Manager Keith Trefethen said during a telephone interview on Tuesday.

Advertisement

Issues between the town and Dubois have been going on for a number of years, Town Planner Tad Redway said by telephone last week.

In 2000, he said, Dubois was required to get a solid waste permit to operate its composting facility when they started importing material to compost rather than just using product produced on its land.

Permits were to be renewable every three years. The last one issued by the town for Dubois’ facility was in 2011; it ran out in 2014.

As part of the consent decree, the town agreed that it would “do away with the local level of performance standards,” said Trefethen, and instead rely on reviews by the Department of Environmental Protection.

On June 26, 2017, the DEP issued a notice of violation, or NOV, against Dubois Livestock, outlining 14 violations ranging from nuisance odors, to off-site leachate discharge, not operating a compost facility that meets design requirements, improper record-keeping and not answering questions about the compost facility.

According to the NOV, a number of corrective actions by Dubois were required. The DEP declined to respond as to whether any of those actions have been completed or what further action it may take against the company.

Advertisement

“It is DEP’s policy not to comment on open enforcement cases; therefore I am unable to comment on updates or possible action at this time,” DEP spokesman David Madore said in an email Tuesday.

In order for the Planning Board to approve a permit for the compost facility, Redway said, “the (town’s) code enforcement officer has to verify that they are in compliance with state regulations and when he spoke to the state (staff) they said (Dubois) is not in compliance.” Because of this, the Planning Board could not issue a permit, he said.

Dubois’ Fedder had a difference of opinion earlier this month.

“It’s very clear that you had no discretion to deny that permit,” he told Planning Board members at their Aug 10 meeting.

“On the first page of the consent decree,” he said it states, “grant it based on one issue or grant it based on another issue … but I can see nothing that permitted you to do anything but grant that permit based on that consent decree.”

The consent degree states on page one that “The performance criteria specified in the (land use ordinance) for the issuance and reissuance of all solid waste processing facility renewal permits at the site, hereinafter shall be deemed to have been satisfied by the submissions described below or deemed inapplicable as result of Dubois’ grandfathered status.”

Advertisement

The submissions, which were due July 1, include an accurate site plan and obtaining a letter from the CEO confirming the operation is in compliance with state licenses and regulations.

Although Dubois was not able to secure a letter of compliance from the CEO, Fedder said the company must be granted the permit based on its grandfathered status.

Trefethen disagreed. “To make an argument that the grandfathered status stands alone, it’s laughable,” he said.

A letter from company president Randy Dubois dated Aug. 7 to Trefethen indicated if the Planning Board did not reverse its position and issue a permit it plans to appeal the decision by today.

Dubois Livestock representatives did not respond to calls prior to press time.

— Associate Editor Dina Mendros can be reached at 282-1535, ext. 324, or dmendros@journaltribune.com.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.