ALFRED ”“ The mother of an Old Orchard Beach man accused of stabbing his grandmother to death and setting fire to her home said her son did not commit the crime.
Derek Poulin, 26, is currently on trial for arson and intentional, knowing or depraved indifference murder. He has been accused of stabbing his grandmother, Patricia Noel, to death in her Old Orchard Beach home in 2012, and then setting the house on fire. Noel was found dead by firefighters who responded to the fire Oct. 23, 2012. Poulin and his father lived in Noel’s house but were not home when firefighters arrived on the scene that day around 2 p.m.
Former Chief Medical Examiner Margaret Greenwald testified last week there was no soot in Noel’s trachea, proof that Noel was not breathing at the time of the fire.
Assistant Attorney General Leane Zainea said last week that a knife Noel was stabbed with was used so many times it was bent, and the handle broke off a golf club used to beat her. Noel was found with dents in her skull matching the shape and size of a wrench used to beat her, said Zainea.
Poulin told police on the day of his grandmother’s death that he was in Portland running errands and visiting his mother. He told police he was at the Bureau of Motor Vehicles around noon that day and at a dental clinic around 1 p.m., but video from the BMV surveillance camera shows he was there around 2:15 and computer records at the dental clinic show he as at the office around 4 p.m.
After receiving the news of his grandmother’s death by a phone call from his father, it took Poulin an hour and 10 minutes to arrive back to Portland, stopping on the way to Catholic Charities thrift shop, where he reportedly bought an item of clothing; clothing Poulin gave police and said he wore the entire day of his grandmother’s death do not match the clothing he was seen in on video taken at the BMV.
Poulin’s mother, Kathleen Emery, testified in court Tuesday.
Emery broke down in tears Tuesday when her son’s attorney, Amy Fairfield asked her about Noel. “She was amazing,” she said.
Emery said she was in court to support her son. “I love him very, very much,” she said. “I’m also here for Patty, because whoever did this to her needs to be punished.”
“Even if it’s your son,” said Fairfield.
“Yes, but I know it’s not,” said Emery.
Emery said she first saw Poulin at her home on Oct. 23, 2012 around 3 p.m., but she believes he was at her apartment earlier when she was not at home because there was a piece of paper on the kitchen table with his writing on it, though she told Assistant Attorney General Donald Macomber that she did not ask her son about the note afterward.
Emery said she had talked to her son the night before Noel’s death, inviting him over to her apartment for dinner the next day and giving him some “tough love” by suggesting he go out and take care of some errands instead of complaining about them.
Emery said after Poulin got off the phone with his father the afternoon of his grandmother’s death, “He went white,” and started shaking.
“He was absolutely devastated. He was in shock,” she said.
Emery said she made her son stay at her home for about 15 minutes before driving back to Old Orchard Beach because he was so visibly shaken.
Emery said Poulin has always avoided crying when upset, and driving off in his car is one of the ways he processes upsetting news. Going to the thrift store on the way home was part of his way “of getting himself together,” she said.
Poulin’s attorney, Amy Fairfield, noted last week that Poulin’s stepfather, who he is very close to, works at a music store in the same strip mall where the thrift store is located.
Chris Stanford, investigator with the Maine State Fire Marshal’s office, said he went to Emery’s home the night of Noel’s death to talk with Poulin, who was staying at his mother’s home that night.
Stanford said when he asked Poulin how he was doing, Poulin said, “He was doing great.” Stanford said Poulin responded in a “gleeful” tone of voice, and didn’t sound like someone who was upset.
Stanford said when he told Poulin he was sorry for his loss, Poulin replied he was happy to have a place to stay, but did not ask any questions about his grandmother’s death.
Stanford talked with Poulin that evening about Poulin’s car and other topics, and Stanford said Poulin was very matter of fact and upbeat.
— Staff Writer Liz Gotthelf can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 325 or egotthelf@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less