3 min read

ALFRED — The defense in Derek Poulin’s trial began questioning witnesses Wednesday, focusing questions on Poulin’s father.

Poulin has been on trial since June 10 for arson and intentional, knowing or depraved indifference murder. He has been accused of stabbing and beating his grandmother, Patricia Noel, to death in her Old Orchard Beach home, then setting the house on fire on Oct. 23, 2012.

Firefighters found Noel’s body after breaking into the home around 2 p.m. that day. Derek Poulin and his father, Reggie Poulin, both lived there but were not at the home when firefighters arrived on scene.

Medical examiners did not find soot in Noel’s trachea, leading officials to believe that she died before the fire broke out. More than 70 stab wounds were found on her body, which was discovered on the floor in her bedroom and adjoining bathroom. The blade of a knife found in the shower stall was bent from so much use, said Assistant Attorney General Leane Zainea, and the handle of a golf club found in the shower stall was broken off. Wounds had dented her skull in the shape of a wrench; a wrench that was used to beat her was found in the shower stall, said Zainea.

Over the past four and a half days, the prosecution has focused on proving that Derek Poulin is guilty, breaking down his alibi for where he was on Oct. 23, 2012. State Police Detective John Hainey said a letter written by Noel found on the dining room table of her home said she wanted Poulin to find a new place to live.

Advertisement

A reddish-brown stain found on Poulin’s boots proved to be blood, but couldn’t be linked to Noel, though her DNA was found on his boots.

Reggie Poulin came to the house late in the afternoon on Oct. 23 after working that day at a landscaping company, and police say he was visibly upset when he was told the news about his mother’s death and the fire.

Wednesday afternoon, Amy Fairfield, attorney for Derek Poulin, interviewed Jason Billings, a manager of Lawn Dawg, where Reggie Poulin has worked for several years applying pesticide and doing other lawn-care work.

Fairfield had Billings go over the list of jobs in the Falmouth and Yarmouth areas on Oct. 23, 2012. The last record of his work at a job site was at 12:22 p.m. that day, and he clocked out at the Riverside Avenue, Portland office at 3:44 p.m.

Assistant Attorney General Donald Macomber asked Billings if Reggie Poulin could have made the 12:22 documentation at the beginning of his time at the work site, and Billings said he could have. Billings also told Macomber that Reggie Poulin could have spent close to an hour that day doing paperwork, showering and changing out of his uniform, and loading the work truck for the next day.

Darcy Daniels, Reggie Poulin’s sister, said that her brother lived with her for three months after the fire, and received $70,000 of insurance money to fix up the house after the fire.

Private Investigator and former police officer Kevin Cady, who was hired by Fairfield, said he interviewed Reggie Poulin on Nov. 27, 2012, about a month after Noel’s death, and collected the clothing and sneakers worn by Reggie Poulin on Oct. 23, 2012. He said he sent the sneakers to a forensics lab in Texas. The results were not discussed Wednesday, and court adjourned early, as Fairfield said her next witness would be arriving that night from Texas.

— Staff Writer Liz Gotthelf can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 325 or egotthelf@journaltribunecom.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.