BIDDEFORD — Cumberland County District Attorney Stephanie Anderson has declined to review Matt Lauzon’s claims that he was sexually abused as a teenager by a retired Biddeford police officer because he did not first agree to a set of conditions, which included handing over his medical records.
In February, Lauzon, a Boston businessman who grew up in Biddeford, first publicly accused former Biddeford Sgt. Stephen Dodd of sexually abusing him as a teenager. Later, he also publicly accused Michael McKeown, a registered sex offender who lives on May Street, of doing the same. Phone calls to Dodd have gone unanswered, while McKeown has said he and Lauzon did have a sexual encounter, but Lauzon was at least 18 years old at the time.
Additionally, Lauzon’s story prompted several others to come forward, alleging abuse at the hands of Dodd as well as former Biddeford detective Norman Gaudette. The Maine Attorney General’s Office conducted investigations of Dodd and Gaudette more than a decade ago, but neither was ever charged.
Lauzon has filed complaints with the Attorney General’s Office against Dodd and McKeown, and in April, a spokesman for the Attorney General’s Office confirmed it is currently investigating allegations of sexual abuse involving a young teenage boy and a former Biddeford police officer but would not elaborate.
Anderson said this morning that York County District Attorney Kathryn Slattery “felt that she had a conflict so she didn’t want to” review the case; the York County District Attorney’s Office would typically review allegations of sexual abuse in Biddeford. Similarly, city officials have said the Biddeford Police Department declined doing an internal investigation to avoid a conflict of interest. For these reasons, the Attorney General’s Office asked Anderson to consider reviewing the case, she said.
But Anderson made certain requests with which Lauzon said he would not comply.
In an email sent from Lauzon’s attorney, Walter McKee, to Anderson on June 10, McKee said, “I do not believe (Lauzon) can ”“ or should have to ”“ agree to certain terms for the case against his perpetrators to be reviewed and prosecuted.”
These terms, according to McKee, included having Lauzon disclose “all of the investigative materials” he has collected to this point, publicly agree that Anderson could conduct the review, agree that she could issue a report detailing the conclusion of her review and sign a medical records release. The last term seemed to be the largest point of contention.
“No,” McKee wrote bluntly in response to Anderson’s request for Lauzon’s medical records. “This is confidential information. Victims aren’t required to give up important privileges to highly sensitive information so that a prosecution can go forward. This information would not address any element of the offense.”
In an email sent to the Journal Tribune Sunday, McKee said he had “never seen anything like” Anderson’s requests. “The fact that Ms. Anderson would not even review the case unless all of her unique conditions were complied with is really quite stunning,” he wrote.
Despite what McKee has said, Anderson said a request for medical records is not unusual given the circumstances. “The request for a medical release is something that we do every case where there may be medical records relevant to an investigation,” she said. “The request was not at all unusual.”
Furthermore, Anderson said a detective at the Attorney General’s Office informed her that McKee is in possession of information about the accusations, which are 17 years old, and she would need that information to review the case. “He and Lauzon have made references to this material they have that allegedly would benefit the prosecution, so that is another thing I wanted,” she said.
Lastly, Anderson said although she did not need to, she gave Lauzon the option to deny having her publicly explain the results of her review, which would have either ended in her filing criminal charges or not. “I was going to explain why and he didn’t like that either,” she said. “Really, he doesn’t have the right to prevent the public disclosure of non-prosecution (information), but I gave it to him anyway.”
Anderson’s decision to not review the case does not prohibit another district attorney in the state or the Attorney General’s Office from eventually prosecuting the case, she said. “My decision doesn’t bar anyone else, but I have to say that I think they’re going to need the same things I need. You need relevant medical records.”
Lauzon said in an email Sunday that he believes at this point, an external organization should be brought in to investigate the situation as a whole.
“BPD Chief Roger Beaupre and the AG’s Director of Investigations Brian MacMaster have both been in place longer than I’ve been alive,” he said. “It’s time for these people to step back and let others investigate the numerous allegations that have come forth during their tenures without any prosecutions.”
— Staff Writer Angelo J. Verzoni can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 329 or averzoni@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less