4 min read

BIDDEFORD — The Planning Board voted 3-1 Wednesday night in favor of allowing an exemption to the city’s shoreland zoning ordinance, as it relates to tree clearing around a stream that runs through Biddeford Municipal Airport.

Now, the City Council must decide whether to pass the exemption, which would allow a nearly $1 million project to address safety concerns at the airport to move forward. The council approved the project in February, after the Federal Aviation Administration informed city officials that trees close to the airport’s runway – in what’s known as the aircraft approach zone – have grown taller than the height it considers safe.

Before the vote, Matt Caron of Gale Associates, the engineering firm that works with the airport, told board members that adhering to shoreland zoning requirements while also bringing the airport up to FAA standards “is just not practical.” The only tree clearing that can be done within a shoreland zone in Biddeford, which stretches 100 feet from the edge of a body of water, is for purposes of timber harvesting.

Several members of the public also spoke at the meeting, airing their concerns over how the shoreland zoning exemption, and the project as a whole, would affect the ecology of the area surrounding the stream, which runs along the southwestern end of the runway, where much of the tree clearing is slated to occur.

“We recommend that you not approve this zoning amendment,” said Denis Rioux, speaking on behalf of the city’s Conservation Commission. “It’s something we don’t think is a good idea.”

Advertisement

Rioux said the area in question is home to vernal pools ”“ temporary pools of water that provide habitat for various species. “They’re a hot bed for biological activity, frogs and various amphibians,” he said. 

Resident and former city councilor Richard Rhames said the “trees that are currently there are providing a cooler and more shaded environment” for the animals that live in the pools, so removing them would disrupt the ecosystem of the area. 

Similarly, in a letter sent to the Planning Board just hours before the meeting, Derek Yorks, a wildlife biologist with the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife, or IFW, said the wetlands around Biddeford Municipal Airport are a known habitat for spotted turtles ”“ a species considered by the state to be threatened, meaning they are one step away from being considered endangered.

“The data we currently have suggests that the spotted turtle population in this part of Biddeford is one of the largest documented in the state of Maine to date and as such it likely represents an important stronghold for the species,” Yorks wrote. “Any conversion of these wetland habitats from their forested state may have negative effects on populations of spotted turtles and vernal pool breeding amphibians.”

City Councilor Clement Fleurent also addressed the board during the meeting, saying he simply doesn’t believe the trees pose a safety concern. “Prove to me where the trees are,” he said. “I haven’t seen any plane crashes caused by trees.”

Fleurent also said in the past, he has suggested installing a light as an alternative to clearing trees but that proposal “fell on deaf ears.” Frederick Oliver, vice chair of the Airport Commission, later indicated a light would not address the fact that the trees currently force pilots to depart from and land at the airport at an unusually steep angle. 

Advertisement

In response to the public’s concerns, Caron said he wanted to make it “abundantly clear” that an exemption to the shoreland zoning ordinance wouldn’t allow for “willy-nilly clear cutting.”

 The airport would work with the Maine Department of Environmental Protection and IFW to ensure the trees are cleared in the least ecologically disruptive way possible, he said, the ultimate goal being to “clear trees yet protect the turtles and other significant resources that are out there.”

Furthermore, the project wouldn’t target every one of the trees within the aircraft approach zone, he said. For example, Caron said 800 feet from the end of the runway, trees that are 27 feet or taller would be removed, while a half mile from the runway, only trees that are 126 feet or taller would be removed.

Although the Planning Board ultimately approved sending the shoreland zoning exemption to the council with a positive recommendation, board members seemed hesitant to do so.

Matthew Boutet, who was serving as an alternate board member at Wednesday’s meeting, was the only one to vote against giving the zoning exemption a positive recommendation. “That’s a lot of tree cover in what we’ve heard is a very sensitive area, so that definitely concerns me,” he said.

When asked by board member Richard Potvin what would happen if the city at some point decided not to go through with the project ”“ which included the acceptance of a federal grant to cover 90 percent of its costs, with 5 percent being paid for by the city and 5 percent by the state ”“ Caron said the city would essentially default on those grant assurances.

“The city has an obligation and they’ve signed a contract with the FAA to make sure they’re going to clear these approach surfaces,” he said.

— Staff Writer Angelo J. Verzoni can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 329 or averzoni@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.