3 min read

BIDDEFORD — A proposal to add 54 units of senior housing to a seven-acre property on the corner of Granite and West streets was met with backlash from residents of that neighborhood during a public hearing before the Planning Board on Wednesday.

For the proposal to go forward, a zoning change is necessary.

Despite the public opposition, the board voted 3-1 in favor of a zoning amendment that would make the property ”“ which is currently part of the R1A, or single family residential, zone ”“ part of the R2, or multi-family, zone. The City Council will ultimately decide whether to allow the zoning change. It approved, Jim Bernard, who purchased the property 3 1/2 years ago, will move forward with his plans to turn it into a senior housing complex.

Bernard told board members that he had originally proposed adding recreational fields to the property, but the city never showed an interest in that option. “We’re basically in a position where we’re going to have to move forward and develop the property,” he said.

Eight of the 10 members of the public who spoke during the meeting said they opposed the project, arguing it would be out of place in the neighborhood and bring more traffic to an already dangerous and congested intersection.

Advertisement

“I’m opposed to this project because it’s inconsistent with the rest of the neighborhood,” said Rick Ouellette, an abutter to the property in question. The senior housing complex would disrupt “this big oasis of single-family homes,” he said.

Theresa Roy ”“ who lives across from the property, which is known to some as “the horse farm” because it houses a barn where horses are currently kept ”“ said she feared losing “a beautiful piece of property.”

“Our front porch faces the horses, the trees, the barn,” she said. “I understand it’s their property and they should be able to do what they want. ”¦ (But) it’s kind of hard to swallow.”

Theresa Roy’s husband, Scott Roy, said it would be a shame to tear down the barn as well as a house that sits on the property, both of which were built hundreds of years ago and are, in his opinion, historical landmarks.

The Roys also spoke about the many car accidents they observe near their home, at the intersection of Granite and West streets, and said bringing more vehicles to the area would be a poor decision.

“The corner is very congested as it is,” said Theresa Roy. “It’s the common walking route. Everybody walks by and rides bikes and we have accidents on that corner all the time. So then you add another 55 units and possibly (vehicles), it’s going to be even more congested.”

Advertisement

Ray Cote, who lives on Granite Street, was the only person to definitively speak in favor of the project. “I would much rather see 54 units of elderly people than to see 20 individual homes there,” he said.

Cote also contested that the intersection isn’t as dangerous as others were claiming.

In response to the many complaints, Bernard said he realizes the beauty of the barn and its horses, but it’s not financially feasible for him to continue to maintain an undeveloped property. To address some of the residents’ concerns over the housing complex’s aesthetics, Bernard, who also developed the Eastwoods Retirement Community on Hill Street, said he would keep the units below two stories and at least 40 feet from the property line.

Although there was some debate, Planning Board members ultimately seemed to favor the proposed development project. “I think this is a perfect fit for that piece of property,” said board member Larry Patoine.

Board member Richard Potvin said in general, he favors development that entails a mix of building types, such as condo complexes melded with single-family houses.

City Planner Greg Tansley also voiced his support for the project, indicating that the property lies in a designated growth area and is already connected to city water and sewer lines. Tansley also said calculations show that at peak traffic hours, 54 units of senior housing would generate a quarter of the vehicle trips that 20 single, detached houses would.

“At the staff level, we think it’s a good proposal,” he said.

— Staff Writer Angelo J. Verzoni can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 329 or averzoni@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.