4 min read

Only two of Maine’s 259 high school varsity soccer teams finished 2017 undefeated and untied: the Yarmouth boys, who collected their 4thconsecutive Class B title with a 2-1 victory over Winslow, and the Yarmouth girls, who won their 2nd straight Class B Gold Ball with a 9-0 crushing of Presque Isle.

Disclosure: I’ve coached youth soccer in a neighboring town for nearly a decade, and while we’ve rarely beaten Yarmouth, their coaches and players have always shown nothing but respect for their opponents.

Full disclosure: Okay, I only remember a Cumberland team besting Yarmouth once. And that was, perhaps not coincidentally, when my son’s head coach was someone other than his dad!

The now four-time defending Class B boys state champion Clippers were dominant this season, scoring 76 goals while allowing only ten. But it probably wasn’t coincidence they didn’t reach double-digits in any of their 14 wins. They won one game 9-0 and scored seven goals in four others, but sometimes it’s difficult for a highly-skilled team to avoid amassing high goal totals against an undermanned opponent.

I know that from experience. Nearly 30 years ago a high school junior varsity soccer team I led walloped an outclassed opponent 11-0 despite my making every possible effort to keep the score down. The opposing coach understood the situation and wasn’t upset, but I felt far worse after that game than I did several months later when the basketball team I directed absorbed a 104-39 beating from a far superior opponent that was still applying a full-court press in the 4th quarter. The difference? When our team was getting slaughtered I had no control over the opposing coach’s tactics, but when my squad was superior I felt at least partially responsible for a one-sided drubbing that didn’t benefit any of the parties involved.

Advertisement

Good coaches do all they can to avoid embarrassing an opponent, partly out of common decency but also because the smart ones know that in sports as in life, what goes around often comes around.

Interscholastic and youth sports are important, but just how impactful they are is a matter of opinion. Athletics are, like other extracurricular activities, a potentially valuable component of a well-balanced childhood, and participating in them should result in multiple positive (or at the very least non-negative) outcomes.

While the season ended triumphantly in Yarmouth, nine Maine varsity teams lost every soccer game they played this fall. Hopefully the players, coaches, and families of the 0-14 boys high school teams at Skowhegan, Nokomis, Penquis Valley, Dirigo and Machias Memorial and the winless, draw-less female squads at Maine Girls Academy, Fryeburg Academy, Washington Academy, and Valley got something from their just-completed seasons. But getting outscored 137-3 and losing by scores of 12-0, 15-0 (twice) and 16-0, as Washington Academy’s girls did, can make finding a silver lining challenging. It’s difficult to understand how or why a coach would allow his or her team to humiliate any opponent, particularly one that’s already absorbed multiple double-digit beatdowns. Nothing good comes from a strong team humiliating an inferior one in any sport, and doing so does a disservice to all involved.

Ideally every well-rounded young athlete would experience being a member of a championship team at some point, but should also play for one that loses a championship game, or one that struggles to win any games at all. Everyone should get a chance to be a star or key contributor, but also experience the disappointment and frustration of being a seldom-used spare part as well.

The most important takeaways from participating in competitive athletics should be, in no particular order: being a part of something bigger than one’s youthful self; learning the value of hard work and collaboration in achieving a goal; realizing the importance of (and getting in the habit of) maintaining physical fitness; learning how to handle success and deal with defeat gracefully; and forging lifelong friendships.

Too much winning is, in the long run, no better than too much losing.

Advertisement

Several years ago my sons and I witnessed our hometown Greely Rangers win the Class B baseball championship. During the postgame celebration on the field someone nearby commented, “This has got to be the greatest day of their lives.” And maybe it was, but here’s a sobering thought for the players on that team: what if winning that single baseball game still holds that distinction 20 years from now?

The folks in Yarmouth are no doubt looking forward to watching their two high school teams attempt to repeat as state soccer champions in 2018. But if they really want what’s best for the players, perhaps Clipper fans should root for a gut-wrenching loss or two along the way.

 


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.