Gov. John Baldacci and his commissioner of education are open to alternative school consolidation plans – as long as they save the same amount of money as the governor’s proposal, which reduces the number of districts in the state from 290 to 26.
“We’re open,” said Commissioner Susan Genrdon, but only if those alternatives cut administrative costs to the same degree as the governor’s plan, improve the quality of education and are sustainable for the future.
Baldacci’s numbers, which have been challenged at a series of largely hostile meetings sponsored by the administration and the Legislature, claim the governor’s proposal would save $240 million over three years in combined state and local education spending.
Of that amount, $36 million is already booked in the second year of the governor’s two-year state budget for fiscal years 2008 and 2009, meaning the money will have to come from somewhere to keep the budget balanced. The rest isn’t counted in any official budget yet, but is supposed to be realized in 2010 and 2011.
But the governor’s plan gives little insight into how the savings will be achieved, since they are simply described as per student or percentage reductions in current spending in four areas: central administration, special education, transportation and operation and maintenance of facilities.
That lack of detail is frustrating school administrators, who say they need to know what the governor really wants in order to make it happen.
“Don’t make us fly the plane while were building it,” Boothbay Harbor Superintendent Eileen King-McGuire told the Legislature’s Education Committee last week.
King-McGuire, who serves as vice president of the Maine School Superintendents Association’s executive committee, said superintendents just want to know what’s expected of them, and she can’t believe the ultimate goal is 26 school districts.
“I’m hoping the governor and the commissioner laid this plan out to shock us and to force the conversation, and the final plan will be far less drastic. That’s the only way I can go through this with any sense of sanity,” King-McGuire said, adding the proposal to create “26 mega-districts to improve the quality of education and save money doesn’t make rational sense.”
“You’re going to need to add layers and layers of personnel to those mega-districts,” to make them work, she said, because “you’re moving them so far away from the students.”
An alternative that is expected to be introduced this week with the backing of the state teachers union and the Maine Municipal Association would create 26 planning alliances charged with finding 10 percent cost reductions in non-instructional
services starting in July of 2009 – savings achieved a year later than the governor’s proposal. Coalition members say that alternative could be amended to achieve savings earlier in the year to be more in line with Baldacci’s plan.
Governor’s school cuts
Under the governor’s plan, 26 school districts would mirror the regional technical/vocational school districts already in place. There would be 26 superintendents, compared to the current 152, and 26 school boards, compared to the current 290.
The goal is to cut administrative costs from $372 per student to around $204 by not only cutting superintendents, but other central administration staff from clerks to business managers. That is supposed to save just over $41 million each year in state and local education funding, for a total of $124 million over three years.
The other three areas of savings are in special education, transportation and facilities operation and maintenance. There, the governor’s plan just cuts 5 percent off current spending for the first year and another 2.5 percent in the second and third years of the three-year estimate. Those across-the-board percentage reductions would save $62 million in total for special education; $53 million for facilities maintenance and operation; and $24 million in transportation.
Taken all together, those cuts total $261 million at the state and local level, but Baldacci is then calling for reinvesting $21 million so every school has a principal.
Gendron said Baldacci has been open to other proposals from the start, as long as they achieve the same savings, which are $36 million in state spending and $30 million in local spending in fiscal year 2009. But in the same breath, she is not willing to declare the governor’s plan dead.
“We’re seeing e-mails that say ‘stay the course,'” she said, pointing out that many who come to the public meetings are school district personnel. “Who’s been vocal and who’s not been vocal?”
Alternatives considered
The Legislature’s Education Committee appears already to have abandoned the governor’s plan, but it’s not clear yet where members are headed. In hours of discussion last week, they did agree unanimously through straw votes that something should be done to change the existing system. They also unanimously supported the concept of planning alliances, where existing districts would come together to recommend administrative savings. They also called for a reasonable timeline for change with financial incentives for districts to help make it happen.
Those financial incentives, however, could be problematic. While the original law that increased state aid to education to 55 percent of costs by 2009 included a regional incentive fund of $15 million in fiscal year 2008 and $20 million in 2009, that fund was essentially repealed in the governor’s plan, meaning the money was not budgeted.
That means the Education Committee will have to come up with a proposal that not only finds the $36 million in cuts included in Baldacci’s plan, but also funds regional incentives.
The Maine Education Association, which is the union representing the state’s teachers, and the Maine Municipal Association, representing cities and towns, have joined with the Maine Children’s Alliance to craft a compromise. The alliance wrote one of three reports last year calling for school district consolidation to save money, but took a much more grassroots approach than the governor.
Geoff Herman of the MMA said the plan would create 26 planning alliances and give them until February of 2009 to recommend 10 percent cuts in non-instructional services to the boards and town meetings that would have to approve them. Those cuts would have to be in place by July of 2009 in order to have an effect on fiscal year 2010 budgets.
The alliances also would be asked to work with all the school districts in their given region to draw maps of what new districts would look like if existing districts increased student count by 20 percent. “Who might they pair up with?” is the question that would be asked, Herman said.
If the planning alliances didn’t generate 10 percent savings by Jan. 1, 2010, Herman said, the state would take over.
“The commissioner would be authorized to present a reorganization plan for that region,” he said.
The Education Committee continued its deliberations this week with a goal of having something to the Appropriations Committee by early March.
Comments are no longer available on this story