3 min read

Norm Justice, facilities director for Gorham schools, Tuesday explains need to replace major components of the heating/air conditioning system at the town’s middle school. Town councilors rejected sending a measure to referendum in November asking voters to authorize borrowing $2.1 million for the project.

GORHAM — The Town Council Tuesday turned down a School Department request to ask voters in November to borrow $2.1 million to replace the middle school’s heating and air conditioning system.

The referendum request was rejected 4-3 with Town Council Chairman Benjamin Hartwell, Vice Chairwoman Sherrie Benner and Councilors Ronald Shepard and Suzanne Phillips opposed.

“We can’t keep taking out bonds to pay for capital improvements that can and should be planned for, the council has said this in the past when we approved a referendum question for a capital improvement bond for deferred maintenance,” Hartwell said Wednesday in an email.

“I think we need to look at restructuring how capital improvements are funded or where they are funded in the budget,” he said.

Advertisement

“Kudos to our Council for sending a strong message to schools,” resident Jim Means posted Wednesday on Facebook. “Much better planning is needed before asking our over-burdened tax payers for more money.”

Norm Justice, School Department facilities director, presented an overview of the school’s system to the council. Justice said the heat pumps in the geothermal system for heating and cooling are approaching the end of their useful lives.

The school was built in 2002, opened in 2003 and the mechanical system is aging.

“We have 120 heat pumps,” Justice said.

Means advocated at Tuesday’s meeting that the town should take over maintenance of school buildings.

Another resident from the public podium said, “Please do more to plan for these expected maintenance costs.”

Advertisement

The School Department advocates replacing all major components in the middle school’s heating/air conditioning system as the favored option of five outlined in a study presented by an engineering consultant at a joint workshop last month.

The cost jumped up from $1.9 million to $2.1 million in a revision on Aug. 29 “due to uncertainty of bidding climate.” Means said the replacement had been projected to cost $1.3 million in February.

The request for a referendum to finance the heat pump replacement project came as school officials plan a referendum next year for a multi-million dollar high school renovation/expansion project.

“The high school is around the corner,” Means pointed out.

According to a School Department, replacing all major components in the middle school system would be the lowest overall cost. It would mean equipment would be the same age and from the same manufacturer and would be installed by the same contractor.

“Everything has to done at the same time,” said Town Councilor James Hager, a former School Committee member and chairman.

Advertisement

Justice said the benefits of a total replacement benefits include improved efficiency, the need for fewer heat pumps and a 15-20 year life expectancy. He  said such a project would be the least disruptive to the building and occupants.

The type of refrigerant used in the middle school air conditioning system will be banned from manufacturing in 2020, he said.

An option to replace heat pumps as they fail would cost $10,000 each, equaling $1 million in “today’s dollars,” according information provided by the School Department. 

Town Councilor Paul Smith asked about the cost of switching the school to a conventional system and Justice replied that cost would be $4.1 million plus added energy costs.

“It was a bad investment,” Smith said. “Bite the bullet and move on.”

Under a referendum to borrow money for replacing the major components, school district finance officer Hollis Cobb estimated town could get a 2.75 percent interest rate for a 10-year bond.

Advertisement

Superintendent Heather Perry said bond payments would go into the school budget.

The Town Council did unanimously approve a referendum for Nov. 6 to allow the School Department to join the Greater Educational Alliance, a coalition aimed at reducing school operating costs.

A public hearing is scheduled for Tuesday, Oct. 2, in the municipal center, 75 South St.

Robert Lowell can be reached at 854-2577 or email rlowell@keepmecurrent.com.

Comments are no longer available on this story