5 min read

South Portland city councilors and department heads took part in a two-hour diversity training session Monday, even as the city faces a complaint filed recently with the Maine Human Rights Commission by a black woman the council did not appoint to a volunteer city committee this past spring.

While the Maine Human Rights Commission is not able to verify if a complaint has been filed, Mayor Tom Blake told the Current this week that South Portland has received a letter notifying it that Deqa Dhalac contacted the commission in regard to a decision she believes was made on the basis of race.

Blake said the two events are unrelated, but on Monday, Councilor Brad Fox told the Current he pushed for the council to hold diversity training partly because of what happened with his nomination for Dhalac to serve on the Civil Service Commission back in March.

Fox said in an interview that being inclusive is not something that just happens, it’s something that must be proactively worked at.

“With no minorities on the boards and commissions that serve the city, we are not taking advantage of a great resource,” he said.

“I live in a very diverse neighborhood on the west side of town where there are thousands of people from all around the world,” said Fox, who represents District 5. “By not reaching out and making them feel part of the system, the city is missing out.”

Advertisement

Fox nominated Dhalac to a five-year term on the Civil Service Commission, instead of moving to re-appoint Phillip LaRou, whom Fox had successfully nominated to the panel more than a year ago to fill an unexpired term.

Dhalac came to the United States from Somalia nearly 30 years ago, and in defending his choice, Fox said the city needs to see more diversity on its citizen-led boards and commissions.

In a prior interview following Dhalac’s failed appointment, Fox told the Current, “We clearly need to do continual outreach to our multicultural community to make them feel included in our civic life. Their incredible histories and talents need to be celebrated and we need them to participate, not be hidden away, as they have been for so long.”

In a 5-2 vote, the council decided to keep LaRou on the Civil Service Commission based on his exemplary service during his initial term and due to his experience, particularly with fire departments. The Civil Service Commission is responsible for public safety personnel decisions in South Portland.

The councilors who supported re-appointing LaRou to the commission were clear that their decision was not based on Dhalac’s ethnicity or her competence to serve, but on the fact that LaRou was already doing a good job.

Neither Fox nor Blake would comment specifically on Dhalac’s complaint with the Maine Human Rights Commission, but Fox told the Current prior to Monday’s diversity training session that “there are no faces of diversity at city meetings. We need to be proactive, raise our awareness and challenge our thinking.”

Advertisement

Fox said prior to Monday’s diversity training, “This is about making the city better and stronger. I am pretty excited about it and feel like it’s the most important thing I’ve done while serving on the council.”

In addition to serving on the City Council, Fox is also the Democratic candidate for the District 33 seat in the Maine House of Representatives this fall. He will face off against Republican state Rep. Kevin Battle.

While Blake, the mayor, said there was “absolutely no connection” between Dhalac’s complaint with the Maine Human Rights Commission and the session on diversity, he was still fully in favor of holding the training.

“I think it’s a good idea and I am very supportive,” he said Monday. “We live in a very diverse community and we need to be knowledgeable and up to date.” That said, Blake added, “Quite honestly I think we do very well as an equal opportunity employer.”

Following the diversity training, Blake told the Current he felt the session was “very positive, cheerful and interactive.” He said the council left it up to the department heads in attendance to make a recommendation for any next steps.

In terms of the civil rights complaint made by Dhalac, this week Amy Sneirson, executive director of the Maine Human Rights Commission, outlined the process that follows an accusation of wrongdoing.

Advertisement

She said complainants have 300 days from the date of the alleged discrimination to file a complaint, and said the elements required for the issue to move forward vary depending on the type of claim presented.

Sneirson also said that “every investigation is completely different, so what we look at can vary widely. We begin each case by notifying the company/person being sued (and) in most every case, we send the complaint to the respondent and also come up with our own list of information the commission wants to know.”

She added, “The respondent’s answers to the complaint and to the commission’s request for information are very important for us to consider (and) oftentimes, after considering those initial pleadings on paper, the investigator will meet or talk to the parties and/or witnesses, or ask for additional information.”

When trying to determine the validity of a civil rights violation, Sneirson said, “the credibility of parties and witnesses can be critically important. (But), ultimately, the complainant has the burden of proving his/her claims.”

She said, “Our legal standard for finding reasonable grounds to believe discrimination occurred is whether it is at least as likely as not that the complainant could prove his/her claims in court.”

If a case is not dismissed or resolved at the administrative level, Sneirson said a public hearing could be held before the board of commissioners. She said that if the commission finds reasonable grounds for the complaint, then the commission is required to try to resolve the case. If no resolution is reached, then within 90 days the complainant has the right to file a lawsuit in court.

Overall Sneirson said her agency receives between 600 and 800 complaints per year and said “on average we resolve cases within a year and fully-investigated cases in about 18 months.”

Dhalac did not respond to the Current’s request for comments before the newspaper’s deadline Tuesday.

Comments are no longer available on this story