4 min read

When Michael Thurlow joined the Scarborough Fire Department 33 years ago, at age 16, firefighting was more like a demanding hobby than a profession. Training requirements were minimal, and Scarborough’s firehouses were neighborhood activity centers. Volunteerism was high; calls were low.

“(The firehouse) was the center of the community and the neighborhood,” recalls Thurlow, who lived in Pine Point. “There was a lot of activity there.”

Thurlow was a third-generation firefighter. A lot of his neighbors were volunteer firefighters, as well.

But things have changed considerably since 1980. For one thing, Scarborough has nearly doubled in population, from 11,347 residents to a 2010 estimate of more than 20,000. Calls have more than tripled, from 1,048 to 3,283 in 2007.

And volunteer numbers are dropping. In 1980, the fire department had 318 call members, or residents who are paid a small hourly rate to respond to emergencies. Today, it has only 147.

The bottom line, town officials say, is that Scarborough is getting too big for a fire department with only 13 full-time employees.

Advertisement

“Ten years from (now), we’re looking at 18 calls per day and 10 years from that is up to 35 calls per day,” Thurlow said. “It’s just obvious that a call force is not going to be able to meet that demand without assistance.”

His concerns aren’t falling on deaf ears. Town Manager Ron Owens asked the Town Council last week to add four full-time firefighter/EMTs and two full-time paramedic lieutenants to the department in next year’s budget, the first step in a nine-year plan to get the fire department fully staffed.

“(W)e have reached a point where the growth in the community and volume of emergency calls for service is quickly outpacing the call members’ ability to continue to provide that service without some assistance,” Owens told councilors.

Owens asked the council to hire four full-time fire department employees per year for the next nine years, which would result in one full-time employee on each of the department’s engines and ladder trucks, and two on the rescue units.

Currently, the department’s only full-time staff members are the chief, two deputy chiefs, two paramedics and eight paramedics. Because the fire department operates 24 hours a day, eight paramedics on staff translates into only two on duty at any one time, one in Oak Hill and one in Dunstan. The department supplements its staff with per-diem EMT/firefighters and fire science students who live in the firehouses and work in exchange for rent.

“You see the commercial development that’s occurring in town. Eventually you’ll have more businesses, more activities, more offices, which will also generate more demand on rescue,” Owens said. “We have to face the reality that over time, we’re going to have to add more people.”

Advertisement

While the decline in call members is magnified by Scarborough’s growth, it’s an issue of its own that is mirrored across the nation, Thurlow said.

“It’s a combination of things,” Thurlow said. “Most families now have two working parents, which back 20 years ago wasn’t necessary. There are more state and federal regulations. The training requirements are significantly more than they used to be. It’s a profession now, compared to what could have been a hobby years ago.”

Because fewer young people are joining up, the average age of the department’s call members is 38.

The time commitment can also be a turnoff for people. Because the department now gets about nine calls a day, the town’s busiest company responded to about 1,000 calls last year. For some firefighters, that can mean working all day, attending to family demands and then getting called out in the middle of the night, sometimes more than once.

“We’ve got a good, dedicated staff of call members,” Thurlow said. “But with the less serious calls, smoke investigations and some of the others … it just becomes harder and harder to get people to go. It’s part of the national trend that we’ve just got less call members who are able to step up to the plate and make the commitment.”

Call members are paid between $8.83 and $15.15 per hour, based on experience.

Advertisement

According to the U.S. Fire Administration, the number of volunteer firefighters nationwide decreased from 897,750 in 1984 to a low of 770,100 in 1989 and stood at roughly 800,050 in 2003, the last year for which statistics are available. During roughly the same time period, from 1980 to 2000, the nation’s population increased 25 percent.

In a report on recruitment challenges, the Fire Administration cited two-income households, less community involvement and more transient families as contributing to the problems.

But by far the biggest stressor on Scarborough’s fire department, town officials say, is growth – commercial as well as residential.

“(The population of 18,000) – that’s just permanent residents,” Owens said. “That doesn’t take a look at the people who come to shop, who come to work in the town. We do import more people daily to work in town than we send out of town to work.”

Thurlow said South Portland, which has roughly the same population and number of calls, has 64 full-time firefighters.

“We’re 54 square miles,” he said. “Old Orchard, Cape Elizabeth, Westbrook and South Portland can geographically fit within our borders … Scarborough protects one of the highest valuations in the state, over $3.5 billion. We do that covering more stations than any other community and we are doing it with significantly less staff than any other departments.

“In 10 years, our calls double; in 10 more years they double again,” he said. “You really can’t wait until you’re in crisis.”

Comments are no longer available on this story