A plan to limit large fuel tucks on a residential stretch of Broadway drew tough opposition Monday night from independent carriers, oil dealers and the Maine Department of Transportation.
Both truckers and state officials warned the South Portland City Council that there is not an easy alternative route for truckers traveling from the city’s tank farm to westerly destinations, such as Buxton, Gorham and Steep Falls.
They also noted that federal regulations prohibit 18-wheelers carrying fuel from traveling on interstate highways, which preclude the use of Interstate 295 in South Portland when the tankers are full.
“A lot of folks were assuming that trucks that weigh 80,000 pounds when filled with fuel could travel on 295,” Mayor Jim Soule said after a City Council workshop Monday night.
The City Council had just discussed whether to restrict the large tanker trucks from traveling on Broadway, from the intersection of Route 1, known as Cash Corner, to the intersection of Westbrook Street, known as Crockett’s Corner.
The one-mile stretch is where many homes are located, and residents have complained for years about the noise, speed and emissions from the fuel trucks.
Councilor Tom Blake, who is a retired firefighter, recalled being summoned to many serious accidents at Crockett’s Corner.
Like most councilors Monday night, Blake said he favors reducing heavy truck traffic on Broadway.
Councilor Jim Hughes said he first became involved in city politics because of his concerns about the number of fuel rigs traveling on Broadway, where his home is located.
Oil rigs heading to and from the oil tank farm, near Portland Harbor, rattle homes, and the vibrations have cracked basements.
Soule said he believes the ideal, long-range solution is a designated truck route. One proposal heard Monday night would be to develop old rail lines that skirt the city as dedicated truck routes.
Councilors noted that the city is in an unusual position, because of the oil tank farms that receive shipments through Portland Harbor that serve New England.
On Monday night, councilors talked about rerouting truck traffic or limiting the large oil rigs to day or nighttime hours.
Fuel trucks and other large trucks that do business in the city would not be affected by the rules.
The alternative route proposed would require truckers to exit Broadway at Main Street, or Route 1, and then travel south to the Route 703 spur, which leads to the Maine Turnpike.
Some truckers already use this route, though it is slightly longer and there are more traffic lights, said Ken Cannell, spokesman for C.N. Brown & Co., which carries about 80-90 loads of fuel daily from the tank farm to convenience stores it owns in Maine and New Hampshire.
“We do not dispute that there is a problem,” Cannell said. “We just hope we can get together with the city to discuss alternatives.”
Cannell noted that the trucks leaving the tank farm with fuel are not traveling Broadway to access Interstate 295. They are driving west to destinations, often using Western Avenue, off Westbrook Street. He said truckers often go to Cornish, Hollis and Gorham.
He said Broadway, which intersects with Westbrook Street, provides the most direct route.
But, Hughes noted that trucks using the Route 703 spur – off Route 1 – can take Route 114, which travels west. “It’s not like people can’t get there from here,” Hughes said.
Chris Jackson, spokesman for the Maine Oil Dealers Association, said that the skyrocketing costs of gas also make it difficult for truckers to travel longer distances to avoid residential areas in cities.
He said carriers are concerned that if South Portland imposes restrictions on truck traffic in neighborhoods, other municipalities will follow suit.
“Every residential neighborhood with concerns will look at South Portland,” Jackson said. “Truck traffic prohibitions are poor public policy.”
He suggested that the city work with the truckers to create a voluntary practice of using an alternative route instead of Broadway. He said trucking companies have started blocking Broadway as a route on the GPS devices in trucks.
Likewise, Steve Landry of the Maine Department of Transportation said the state is not receptive to the idea of closing or banning roads to traffic.
Broadway is a state-maintained road that would lose funds if the city restricted or rerouted truck traffic. Landry noted that anyone who buys gas for vehicles in Maine pays taxes that support public roads.
He also advised city leaders to talk with neighbors on Route 1 before establishing an alternative route. “I want to make sure that everyone’s voice is heard.”
Peter Coughlin, who directs the community services division for DOT, said that Maine officials want to “ensure that commerce flows uninterrupted” on state highways.
Resident Jan McNally, who lives at 401 Lincoln St., said she came to the workshop because she is worried that trucks may use Lincoln Street if they are restricted from using Broadway.
McNally said a fuel truck overturned in her yard two years ago, and she was forced to evacuate her home overnight.
Fuel trucks disturbing homes on Lincoln Street, off Broadway, could become more of a problem, if the city moves forward to make Exit 4 a full-service interchange. Currently, only northbound traffic can use Lincoln Street to enter or exit Interstate 295.
The city has received $500,000 to conduct engineering work to rebuild the Lincoln Street ramps.
Councilor Linda Boudreau suggested that the city should prepare a report listing the possible alternatives as well as the obstacles to plans for reducing heavy truck traffic on Broadway.
She said many ideas have been suggested over the years, with the same plans being debated over and over again. Boudreau said the city needs a comprehensive list to move forward.
“We need to develop a matrix that lists the alternatives,” she said at the end of the two-hour discussion. “We may find out at the end of the process that voluntary compliance (by the carriers) is the best alternative. But as it is, we keep spinning our tires.”
Comments are no longer available on this story