2 min read

As the cost of delivering education has increased, more and more school districts have turned to participation fees in order to avoid cutting athletics and other extracurricular activities.

Schools such as Gray-New Gloucester High School, Cape Elizabeth High School and Massabesic High School in Waterboro have already instituted a so-called “pay-to-play” system, and this week school officials in both Scarborough, which eliminated fees two years ago, and Windham-Raymond submitted budgets that include participation fees. South Portland removed from next year’s budget a proposal for a fee system covering most extracurricular activities, but officials will establish a task force to recommend whether the system should be implemented in the future.

For school systems dealing with the ever-rising cost of education coupled with the loss of state aid, pay-to-play can seem like the natural way to maintain extracurricular programs like athletics without raising taxes or diverting money from the classroom. It also, proponents say, forces only those students who participate in extracurricular activities to pay for them.

But participation fees run counter to the ideal of a free, well-rounded public education, which values extracurricular activities and says that each and every student should be given the same opportunities, regardless of an ability to pay. And while most schools with pay-to-play also have some sort of system for waiving the fee, families unable to pay are often reticent to come forward. As a result, some students lose an opportunity they deserve.

“There’s a fine line between what people can afford and what they can’t,” Scarborough Athletic Director Gary Groves of Scarborough told The Current. If the fee is set too high, he said, kids could be deterred from coming out for sports. “You worry about that family that won’t tell you they can’t afford it.”

The fact is that it is difficult with the information available now to ascertain just how pay-to-play is impacting participation. Schools use different fee structures, from one-time fees to per-sport payments, and enforce the waiver system to different degrees. Without that information, it is difficult to tell whether pay-to-play excludes poorer students and should be scrapped altogether.

That is where the Maine Principals’ Association comes in. The organization that runs Maine’s interscholastic athletic tournaments is in a unique position to study pay-to-play in each of its variations across the state and country, and see which structures are more or less exclusionary than others.

At the same time, the MPA and the various athletic conferences that organize scholastic play should take a hard look at scheduling. School budgets are going to continue to rise, and extracurricular activities will always be a target. If savings are available, either from reducing travel or the number of games, at any level varsity or below, then they should be considered.

Because if a solution cannot be found, high school sports, where students learn teamwork and fair play, will either be devastated by budget cuts or forced into a system that treats students differently based on their ability to pay.

Comments are no longer available on this story