Federal student loans have helped millions of Americans with their dreams of attending college and pursuing a productive career. What happens, though, when death or disability cuts those dreams short?
Thankfully, individuals and families can have federal student loans forgiven in cases like this. But there’s a string attached that most families don’t know about until after the fact. The forgiven debt is taxed as a sudden surge of income.
This can amount to tens of thousands of dollars in additional taxes that must be paid the same year the debt is forgiven. What’s more, the income can be substantial enough to put you in a higher tax bracket, so it is subject to a higher rate. If families can’t pay the bill immediately, they may have to deal with additional interest and late fees.
Sadly, I’ve heard from several Mainers who have found themselves in this very challenging situation. Moved by their stories, I’m introducing legislation to help families like them across the country.
The Sangillos, who live in Scarborough, face a similar challenge. Deborah Sangillo had a long career in the insurance industry before deciding to pursue her master’s degree at age 51 so she could become a teacher something she’d always wanted to do. But right before starting her new career, she began to show signs of early onset Alzheimer’s. Today, she lives in a nursing home.
Her federal student loans were forgiven, but her husband, Mark, now has to deal with a tax bill for tens of thousands of dollars on top of caring for Deborah.
“It was pretty rude,” Mark reflected on learning about the tax bill. “I thought if you’re going to forgive the loan, it should be truly forgiven. It’s a real disappointment.”
Thousands of people across the country are in the same situation. In 2012 alone, 57,000 borrowers who passed away had their loans discharged and another 9,500 borrowers had them forgiven after they were determined to be permanently and totally disabled. (Disability standards for loan forgiveness are extremely strict an individual must prove they will have no ability to work for at least five years.)
These families might not represent a large percentage of student loan holders, but that doesn’t take away from how significant this problem is for them. Plus, it just doesn’t seem right. Having these loans forgiven should offer some relief to these families. It shouldn’t create a financial burden that takes years to recover from.
To address the problem, I recently introduced H.R. 4020, the Student Loan Forgiveness Tax Repayment Act. Under the bill, families would still have to pay taxes on the forgiven debt, but they would have 15 years to do so, interest free. And, instead of being taxed as a lump sum, the income would be spread over that 15 years so it is subject to the taxpayer’s normal rate. Finally, the income is excluded from calculations for means-tested federal benefits, so it doesn’t hurt people’s ability to get help from things like food stamps.
It’s hard to imagine how difficult it must be to deal with the disability or loss of a family member – or even your own disability – while being hit with such a huge financial burden. I’m hopeful this legislation will move forward in Congress so we can allow these families to focus on themselves and their loved ones when they need to most.
Chellie Pingree represents Maine’s 1st District in the U.S. House of Representatives.
Comments are no longer available on this story