A restrictive sign ordinance and traffic problems are among the chief complaints cited by Scarborough businesses in a yearlong study conducted jointly by the Scarborough Economic Development Corp. and the Scarborough Community Chamber.
Through visits, focus groups and the Internet, the two organizations surveyed more than 160 randomly selected businesses representing a cross-section of the town’s business community in an effort to improve Scarborough’s business climate and tax base.
On June 18, the two organizations presented their findings to the Scarborough Town Council and recommended that councilors address six specific issues over the next two years.
Findings include:
• Seventy-four percent of the businesses in Scarborough think the business climate is “good” or “excellent.”
• Ninety-three percent think Scarborough is an “attractive business location.”
• Sixty-four percent think geographic location is an important factor in deciding where to locate a business and 44 percent think “community, people and activities” are important; only 1.6 percent think tax incentives are important.
• Asked an open-ended question about what Scarborough could do to improve its business climate, 19 percent of participants said “improve signage.” Other top suggestions were to create an online business directory (10 percent), have more consistency/fairness in regulations (10 percent) and improve traffic (9 percent).
• Forty-six percent of respondents said their biggest challenge is finding and retaining good employees.
• Eighty-nine percent said they are “satisfied” or “very satisfied” with public goods and services (such as police, trash collection, etc.); only 3 percent said they are “not satisfied at all.”
• About 35 percent said local government support of business is good or excellent; 27 percent said it’s fair or poor and 37 percent had no opinion.
• Asked an open-ended question about what issues they would like to see addressed, 22 percent of participants said “traffic improvements,” followed by more/better signage (18 percent) and affordable housing (9 percent).
The joint recommendations to the Town Council are that the town re-examine its sign ordinance; study the impact of traffic on business; create an online, searchable business directory; ensure that all businesses receive equal and effective assistance; and keep fees and taxes low.
Also, the two organizations advised councilors to “value existing businesses and utilize their services whenever possible” in addition to trying to recruit new businesses.
Most of the surveys and business interviews took place last fall, before gas prices and economic conditions were exerting their current effects on Scarborough businesses, noted Julie Bassett, SEDCO’s assistant director.
Bassett said that although most of the survey results were not surprising, she was surprised that so many businesses mentioned having trouble finding and retaining good employees.
“Some people just left it at, they can’t find people who will show up consistently. Other people said, ‘I can’t afford to pay my employees a huge amount of money, and they can’t afford to live here,'” she said.
Bassett said the comments underscore the importance of creating more affordable housing in Scarborough.
“It’s hard to bring in the right type of workers if they can’t afford to live in town,” said Bob Nadeau, chamber president. “The lower hourly range jobs tend to be the hardest to find employees (for).”
Both Nadeau and Bassett said there were a range of sign complaints, ranging from people who wanted bigger signs to people who wanted directional signs and temporary signs.
Councilors said they would be willing to take a closer look at the issues raised by businesses.
“In general, I was pleasantly surprised that people felt that good about doing business in Scarborough,” said Councilor Carol Rancourt. “I do understand about the sign issue. I think that’s always an issue for businesses to be recognizable, and I don’t think there’s an easy answer to that because it is easy to get lost in a jumble (of signs).”
Comments are no longer available on this story