2 min read

Gorham owes a debt of gratitude to John and Rosamond Phinney, whose generous donation of $38,000 has made it possible for the town to reach what seems to be a reasonable compromise on where to put the town’s historic clock.

The money donated by the Phinneys will pay for the restoration of the clock, which would have come out of $75,000 the town set aside last year to repair it.

Using town money to repair the clock without moving it to town property, some argued, would have violated the principle of the separation of church and state. It also created liability problems for the town as it sought to insure its investment in the clock, which has been called “priceless” by the company repairing it.

Under the agreement approved by town councilors Tuesday night, the church will get a 99-year lease to house the clock, for the bargain price of $1 a year. Members of the First Parish Congregational Church are expected to vote on the agreement later this month.

Members of the church should support this agreement, as it is a reasonable resolution to what has been an emotional debate for those involved. It keeps the clock in its rightful and historic home and keeps the town from spending tax money inappropriately.

The emotions surrounding this debate were at their peak at a meeting last month that ended in a 3-3 vote on moving the clock to the new Municipal Center, which left the future location of the clock uncertain. During that meeting, town councilors were faced with the daunting task of making a decision while working through the town’s and their personal entanglements with the First Parish Church.

Advertisement

The town started down the murky path of navigating the separation of church and state when it set aside $75,000 of tax money to pay for repairs to a clock that sits in the First Parish steeple, after it stopped running last year. However, some might argue this debate was predetermined in 1868 when a prominent Gorham citizen, Toppan Robie, donated the clock to the “citizens of this town,” according to a silver plate that was cleaned by the company repairing the clock, and then placed it in a church steeple.

That’s why it seems appropriate that almost a century and a half later a couple of prominent Gorham citizens, John and Rosamond Phinney, the parents of Town Councilor Mike Phinney, have gotten the town out of this mess with a second donation.

If the agreement is approved by church members and the clock works are put on public display in an old organ chamber off the balcony, it would seem also appropriate to put a second plaque there, thanking the Phinneys for their donation and commemorating this debate, another chapter in the history of the town and its clock.

Brendan Moran, editor

Comments are no longer available on this story