CAPE ELIZABETH – Deciding that shooting ranges “merit careful review” in order to “minimize the adverse effects” on abutters, the Cape Elizabeth Town Council voted unanimously Monday to adopt a new ordinance regulating the operation and development of shooting ranges.
The vote followed more than an hour of public comment, during which residents of the Cross Hill subdivision argued that public safety was the most important consideration regarding the continued operation of the Spurwink Rod & Gun Club, which is located at 1250 Sawyer Road and abuts the housing development.
The council approved the new shooting range ordinance over the objections of both gun club members and abutters. The gun club said the new rules were too restrictive and would place an undue burden on the nearly 60-year-old facility.
For the neighbors, the new rules don’t go far enough toward protecting public safety, and many also felt there are too many loopholes in the ordinance, which would allow the gun club to continue operating as it does now.
However, Councilor David Sherman was able to convince his fellow councilors to approve an amendment that requires the gun club to conduct a professional range safety evaluation as part of the new annual licensing process.
Under the new ordinance, all shooting ranges operating in town, along with ones that may be developed, must go through an annual permitting process and will only be allowed to operate if they have “a valid license issued by the municipal officers.” The Spurwink Rod & Gun Club has 180 days from the effective date of the new ordinance to comply with this licensing requirement.
In addition to creating a number of new operational rules, including the hours the shooting range can be used, requiring 100 percent shot containment and noise levels no higher than 65 decibels at the property line, the new ordinance also creates a Firing Range Committee.
According to Town Attorney Ken Cole, the idea behind the committee is to give it as much latitude as possible in establishing the procedures by which existing or new shooting ranges would be evaluated during the annual licensing process.
The committee will consist of five members: one member of the Spurwink Rod & Gun Club who is also a member of the National Rifle Association; one member of the public appointed by the Town Council; one member of the public who is a certified firearms instructor; and two members of the Town Council, one of whom would chair the new committee.
In addition, the police chief and the code enforcement officer would provide staff support to the committee. Any complaints regarding non-compliance with the new rules by any firing range would be first brought to the committee, which would then investigate and prepare a report for the Town Council.
Under the new ordinance, all firing ranges in town must also carry a liability insurance policy of at least $3 million. And in regard to their overall operation, the new rules require firing ranges to meet or exceed the standards specified in the National Rifle Association’s Source Book.
Also, all shooting ranges in town must comply with new warning sign rules, which require that a sign must be placed at 100-foot intervals along the entire perimeter of the shooting range. And, all new firing ranges must be located at least a half-mile from any occupied dwelling.
Under the new rules, each shooting range facility in town must also be secured and have controlled entry and exit points. The firing range ordinance also requires that all such facilities present a site plan to the town, which shows all property lines, a layout of all shooting stations and firing lines and “projected noise contours.”
Overall, the Town Council said its goal with the new firing range ordinance is to “work with the existing shooting range to meet its licensing requirements in a manner that prioritizes public safety and secondarily moderates the financial impact on the club.”
During the public hearing portion of Monday’s meeting, Cross Hill resident Daniel Price said he has three children and was concerned that the Town Council was not interested in making the neighborhood safe for them.
He also argued that non-conforming uses, like the Spurwink Rod & Gun Club, “are a thorn in the side of proper zoning.”
Another resident of Cross Hill, Kathleen Cramer Howe, said the noise and activity at the gun club “are very disturbing” and called on the council to find a compromise that would allow the neighborhood and the gun club to “live in harmony.”
But former gun club president Mark Mayon said requiring the gun club to get an annual license would be like asking a homeowner to reapply for an occupancy permit each year.
He argued that the club has spent a lot of time and money in recent years to modernize the facility, including noise mitigation, and asked the town to give the club time, trust and “breathing room” to complete its upgrade.
“The club wants to be safe and not bother the neighbors,” he added.
New club president Tammy Walter agreed saying, “Ultimately we want to coexist with our neighbors.” And, like Mayon, she asked for time as the gun club moves forward with its modernization and upgrade project.
Comments are no longer available on this story