What Republican Gov. Paul LePage would really like to do is dispose of the entire Maine Department of Health and Human Services. For a fiscal conservative like LePage, that seems reasonable. After all, DHHS spends more money than all but one other state department (education), and it wastes more money than any other state department (with education a not-all-that-close second). It makes an attractive target for a slash-and-burn political campaign.
In the governor’s dreams, the bloated health and welfare system would be replaced by something more focused, something called, I dunno, the Maine Department of Dealing With Poor and Lazy People, maybe. It wouldn’t have any complicated programs, but would begrudgingly hand out money to the destitute to help them buy food or find shelter. Which they would need to do pretty quickly, because after a few of those handouts, there’d be no more. Particularly if the destitute happened to live in Portland. If they couldn’t find a job in Maine’s most economically robust city, they could turn to crime. Or starve. It wouldn’t be LePage’s problem.
I suspect even the guv realizes this is a fantasy. But, hey, a guy can dream.
There’s no question DHHS needs reform. The only question is how the various parties define that word. The GOP envisions reform as a cost-cutting exercise, regardless of the (possibly temporary) human suffering that might cause. Democrats see it as reconfiguring poorly designed and ineptly administered programs to increase their effectiveness, a process that would almost certainly cost more money. And the public, nearly every member of which has seen or heard stories about some worthless slug abusing welfare, wants action, by which a sizable plurality means instituting tighter regulations and stricter deadlines.
In the last election. this issue cost the Democratic Party its majority in the state Senate and a bunch of seats it couldn’t afford to lose in the Maine House. You might think that since then, the donkey party’s leaders would have formulated a plan to assuage the voters’ disgust with wasteful and ineffective government handouts.
But come on, these are Democrats. They conduct their assessments of public opinion during art walks in downtown Portland or at meetings of advocates for a single-payer health care system (motto: It Almost Sorta Worked in Vermont). The solutions that emerge from these efforts are complicated position papers that basically suggest doing nothing.
Which is why Mainers, who’ve traditionally been in favor of sensible efforts to help the less fortunate, are more and more inclined to support LePage’s agenda, which makes almost no distinction between those in need and those who are gaming the system. The governor’s plan is at least comprehensible – cut welfare spending – while the Dems’ muddled response – carefully study any proposed changes to avoid possible unintended consequences – isn’t. A University of New Hampshire Survey Center poll conducted last year for the Portland Press Herald found that 46 percent of respondents thought most welfare spending did more harm than good. Only 43 percent believed the programs were beneficial. The remaining 11 percent were too busy buying scratch lottery tickets with their welfare money to respond.
This explains why LePage is again rolling out a bunch of restrictions he wants to impose on the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program, restrictions that failed in the Democrat-controlled Legislature last year. He’d prohibit using TANF money to buy alcohol, tobacco or lottery tickets. No using welfare cash for bail money. TANF cards would no longer be valid out of state. And to get on the program, applicants would have to show they’d applied for at least three jobs.
There’s no way to enforce most of these rules, but that hardly matters. To lots of working people, these seem like logical changes, because the guv’s idea (screw the cheaters) is far more easily understood than the Democrats’ vague alternative (study doing something – or not).
No wonder LePage keeps repeating the line he used at his inauguration: “Welfare reform is very, very dear to my heart.” It’s already given him a Republican Senate, and in 2016, there’s a reasonable chance it will hand him a GOP-controlled House. Once that happens, who knows what dreams could come true.
The governor might even be able to put his signature on a bill titled An Act to Abolish the Department of Health and Human Services and Replace It With … Well … Not Much of Anything, Because, I Mean, Who Needs It, Y’Know.
If you have thoughts on welfare that are more complex than a Republican’s and more comprehensible than a Democrat’s, email me at aldiamon@hernihill.net.
Comments are no longer available on this story