The Westbrook City Council added last-minute funding of $25,000 to the fiscal year 2015-16 budget for My Place Teen Center on Monday, ending weeks of speculation over where the organization’s annual appropriation would come from, or if it would receive it at all.
The decision wasn’t made quickly. Throughout the two-and-a-half-hour meeting, a number of teen center volunteers and supporters stood up, hoping to sway the council into funding the center, and as a final motion was passed, confusion remained on the conditions included with the funding agreement.
The meeting ended as officials from the city, school department and teen center agreed to work more collaboratively to discuss the teen center funding in future years.
The City Council unanimously gave first-reading approval to the fiscal year 2015-16 total budget, which stands at $58.8 million, an overall increase from this year of $1,564,545. The budget would add 78 cents to the Westbrook property tax rate, the first increase since 2012. The rate would be $17.98 per $1,000 of assessed valuation, or $3,416 for an average home assessed at $190,000.
A second reading on the budget will be held on Monday, May 11. If the budget it approved, the $34.1 million school budget will head to a validation referendum on June 9.
“It’s never been pleasant to come forward with any increase,” said Councilor John O’Hara.
Emotion fueled much of the discussion leading up to the final funding decision. Laurie Whitlock, a long time teen center volunteer and current board member, talked about her difficult personal history and how it affected her life. She said places like My Place Teen Center provide a necessary safe haven for kids who struggle with a variety of factors.
“It’s continued existence and ability to thrive in this community is so important,” she said.
Ben Waxman, who recently moved to Westbrook, said he moved to the city because he was impressed with the community and the services it offered.
“The cost of not investing in children that don’t have a mom and dad after school is a lot more expensive,” he said about the teen center funding.
The $25,000 is flat funded from this year’s budget, representing roughly 5 percent of the center’s $600,000 budget. Teen center Executive Director Donna Dwyer had repeatedly requested $100,000 from the city, but most city officials have countered that $100,000 is on par with the entire social services budget, and that next year’s budget is already resulting in a tax increase for residents.
At $25,000, the teen center still receives more funding from the city than any other social service organization.
Dwyer and other teen center supporters have argued that the city spends far too little on social services.
Westbrook resident Andrew Woody said his son is a regular at the teen center, but not because he doesn’t have two parents.
“He loved the whole atmosphere,” he said.
Referring to the council’s authorization that night to purchase an excavator for $88,000 and a utility truck for $61,000, Woody said, “We just spent $160,000 on two trucks and we’re not going to spend money to help the youth of our city?”
My Place Teen Center is one of 14 nonprofit organizations that receive funding from the city’s social services budget each year. During the last few budget seasons, a social services committee has convened to make funding recommendations to the council.
Mayor Colleen Hilton has said that the social services committee asked the social services agencies to come into this year’s budget discussions with flat-funding requests, given the difficulty surrounding state revenue.
Confusion has surrounded funding for the teen center ever since the social services committee made a recommendation to include $25,000 in the school budget for the center, in return for the school department using the center during off-hours for its alternative learning program.
Two weeks ago, when funding for the center was still undecided, Superintendent of Schools Marc Gousse said the collaboration between the school department and the teen center fell through. He said that after two meetings and a series of emails with Dwyer, no deal was struck.
Gousse said that when he asked Dwyer to share data on the center, including the number of students from Westbrook schools using the space regularly, it wasn’t provided. This was refuted by Dwyer, who said Gousse “pulled the offer” once she reiterated that the teen center would still be seeking its initial funding request of $100,000.
Dwyer has said the center receives no state funding, and other than money from the city, receives money from the United Way of Greater Portland. The organization’s operating budget for next year is $607,000, and it serves 506 kids, she said.
The center was also named an “Agency of Distinction” last year from WCSH-6 and the United Way.
City Councilor Paul Emery read emails from concerned citizens and prior to the budget’s first reading, made a motion to fund the teen center at $100,000, which was opposed 5-2. The added $100,000 would have increased the property tax rate by an additional 5 cents.
“Taking care of our youth is a financial benefit to this community,” he said. “The less problems we have, the better reputation we will get.”
“This is the last minute of a three-month budget process that we’re looking to add $100,000,” said councilor Michael Foley, who chairs the city’s finance committee. “Today we’re being asked to make a decision on emotion.”
At a city finance committee meeting two weeks ago, Emery and Councilor Mike Sanphy both made separate motions to add funds for the teen center, including a motion for $25,000, but both failed.
In response to Emery’s $100,000 funding motion, Foley said that the city is not “dismissing” the work done by My Place Teen Center, but that he would not support a last-minute funding request by any city department, not just social services.
“The teen center does great work,” said Councilor Victor Chau. “But so do all the other social services organizations in the city. I’m not sure how the $100,000 number was planned in your budget.”
Suzanne Salisbury, who chairs the School Committee’s finance committee and serves on the city’s social services committee, said the city is lucky to have a number of agencies that do amazing work.
“Being narrow-minded and only focusing on one place could really be a detriment to our kids,” she said. “We’re at a point where we need to be a little more responsible.”
Leading up to Monday’s meeting, city officials released a letter stating that the city would revisit the teen center funding, and recommended that the council add $25,000 for the teen center, with the condition that a city and school official be added to the teen center board of directors. The condition sparked another rift.
“The suggestion to include representation from the city and schools has to do with my request for the last five years to increase and improve collaboration among our schools with My Place Teen Center,” Hilton said.
However, teen center supporters, such as James Tranchemontagne, said it was unreasonable for the city to made conditions on their funding, as the teen center board is elected through a process.
Sanphy said the $25,000 is a “start in the right direction,” but that going forward there needs to be closer communication.
“We need to sit down with the school board, the teen center and the council as responsible adults and discuss this,” he said.
Dwyer thanked the City Council and other city officials for demonstrating that they care for their city, especially those who had a hand in developing the teen center in the late 1990s.
“I want to commend all of you who had the vision way back then, who carried it forward in its evolution, and want to thank you for your support in the past, and hopefully your support in the future,” she said.
Prior to discussing any budget amendments, councilors commented on the difficulty of this year’s budget process, including the uncertainty stemming from the state budget.
Foley said he was disappointed that the combined city and school budget represents a tax increase, but that the school and city departments “have done their due diligence to have only what is necessary and what we need to provide the best and highest-quality services.”
Comments are no longer available on this story