As of this writing, the baseball world is still waiting, if not with bated breath, at least with some level of anticipation, to hear whether Roger Clemens will play baseball this year.
Will he or won’t he? As the famous Clairol commercial from a few decades ago tantalizingly conjectured – to adjust the wording only slightly – perhaps only his hairdresser knows for sure.
Waiting for Clemens to decide whether to play again has become something of an annual ritual around baseball. Some people surely resent this Hamlet-like spring watch, but others likely envy anyone so thoroughly in charge of his destiny as to be able to decide whether to work or not, and if so, when to start. A whole season? Nah! Take it easy, start in June, stay healthy, wealthy and wise.
Three teams wait with the rest of us: the Houston Astros, Clemens’ current (or is it his previous?) team; the Boston Red Sox, the organization where he reached stardom; and the New York Yankees, with whom he finally won a World Series ring. Red Sox fans have had a love-hate relationship with Clemens since he departed Boston. Pitching for Toronto may have been marginally tolerable, but when Clemens joined the Yankees, he had gone over to the enemy and that really hurt.
Now, though, the consensus seems to be that if Clemens decides to return to the Red Sox, much (if not all) will be forgiven, assuming that he can help Boston return to the World Series. After all, Clemens is the greatest pitcher in the modern history of the Red Sox, maybe the best Boston ever had. The only real competitors are the mythic Cy Young and the flame-throwing Smokey Joe Wood. Young won 511 games, by far the most ever in major league history, although only 192 of them came while pitching for Boston, known as the Pilgrims until 1907. One of the highlights of Cy Young’s tenure with Boston was the 1903 World Series, the first world championship series between the old National League and the new American League that formed in 1901. Young won two games to help the American League upstarts defeat the Pittsburgh Pirates, 5 games to 3. The award given annually to the best pitcher in each league, of course, is named after Young.
Smokey Joe reached stardom for Boston in 1911. The following season, at 22 years of age, he had one of the best seasons ever by any hurler: 34 wins against just 5 defeats; 35 complete games in 38 starts; 10 shutouts; a 1.91 earned run average; and 258 strikeouts in 344 innings. He topped off his extraordinary season by winning three games as Boston bested the New York Giants.
The following year, Wood fell while fielding a ground ball, breaking the thumb on his right throwing hand and injuring his shoulder. He was never again able to pitch without shoulder pain, and by the end of the 1915 season was through, his arm dead, although he did return for a few seasons as an outfielder with the Cleveland Indians before departing for 20 years as the Yale University baseball coach.
Clemens, who pitched for the Red Sox from 1984 through 1996, enjoyed some of the most memorable seasons any Boston pitcher ever had. He won the Cy Young Award as his league’s best pitcher three times while with the Sox, garnering three, 20-win seasons; striking out more than 200 batters eight times; and leading the league in ERA four times. He also picked up the Most Valuable Player Award in 1986, the year he helped Boston reach the World Series, which the Red Sox, helped along by the unforgettable Bill Buckner error, lost to the New York Mets in seven games.
Overall, Clemens leads all Red Sox pitchers in career starts, innings pitched and strikeouts, and is tied with Cy Young in wins. Young, of course, pitched in such a long-gone era that to compare him and Clemens is largely meaningless. Yes, Clemens may be the best that the Red Sox have ever had, and maybe it is all right to cut the guy some slack, especially now that he has accumulated 348 wins and, since leaving Fenway, has added three more Cy Young Awards.
Now in his mid-40s, Clemens remains a dominating fastball pitcher. Few people connected to baseball doubt his ability to continue pitching winning baseball, if he wants to continue the arduous training regimen that he has followed zealously, especially over the second half of his career.
Clemens is a real throwback to the past, a link with the days when great pitchers year after year dominated and intimidated hitters. The era of the great pitcher seems to have passed, and with Clemens and his contemporaries Randy Johnson, Greg Maddux and Tom Glavine nearing the end of their careers, we may not soon see another lengthy stretch of individual pitching greatness, let alone another 300-game winner. Yes, it would be nice to see Clemens take the mound a few more times, even (dare I say it?) in Yankee pinstripes.
Edward J. Rielly is a Westbrook resident, English professor at St. Joseph’s College, and widely published author with three books on baseball and American culture.
Comments are no longer available on this story