3 min read

GORHAM – Dissention on the Gorham Town Council has intensified as one councilor took his colleagues to task on emailing practices he believes are out of bounds.

Matthew Robinson, during the Sept. 4 council meeting, provided the American Journal with a stack of council emails, including ones commenting about the tax rate, a request for a contract zone change, Public Safety Building renovation and questions about group homes in town.

Robinson did not mention any councilor by name or anyone’s specific email at the meeting. He said emails should be utilized to set up council and workshop meeting dates or responding to citizens.

“It’s inappropriate for the council to conduct town business over email or the phone,” Robinson, a former council chairman, said this week in explaining his comments at the meeting. “You were elected to do all town business in public except for executive session.”

No councilors responded to Robinson’s comments at the meeting last week, but several who were contacted this week had plenty to say.

Councilor Matt Mattingly said Wednesday that “it does a disservice to the entire council to suggest there’s back-door wheeling and dealing going on. That’s not the case.”

Advertisement

Gorham provides email accounts for its seven town councilors. The town accounts allow emails to be kept on the town’s server and to be available to the public under the right-to-know act. Mattingly said the public has to be specific with dates, people and items when requesting emails.

Mal Leary, vice president of the Maine Freedom of Information Coalition, said Tuesday town councilors can exchange information by email and that emails between councilors become public records.

“They can’t take any action,” Leary said about councilors utilizing email.

Eric Conrad, director of communications at the Maine Municipal Association, declined comment on the matter because Gorham is a member town.

Gorham Town Councilor Michael Phinney, also a former council chairman, said the council rules allow for seeking information or asking a question by email.

Phinney said Gorham council rules also prohibit decisions made via email.

Advertisement

“It’s a fine line,” Phinney said about conducting business and going too far.

“I think some members have been crossing it (the line),” Robinson said this week, without citing names.

Emails dated Aug. 30 and 31 from several councilors referenced setting the town’s tax rate.

“The mil rate one (email) set me off,” Robinson said.

Mattingly said email communication is a necessity, as councilors have businesses, jobs and families. “We have to be able to communicate quickly,” Mattingly said. “You have so many issues daily, weekly.”

Mattingly said all written communications – even hand-written notes – are subject to the public’s right to know under the Freedom of Information act.

Advertisement

In last week’s Town Council meeting, Robinson also pointed out emails bearing two personal accounts of councilors.

The stack of emails provided by Robinson showed that Mattingly had sent emails from a personal address and Councilor Suzanne Phillips received an email sent to her personal email address.

Mattingly said when he sends an email he also copies it to his email account supplied by the town so there’s a record of it.

Phillips said she thought that someone from the town sent her an email at her personal address in error.

“I do not use my personal email address to do town business,” she said.

Recent Town Council meetings have been marked by squabbles that have included a thwarted attempt by Robinson to publicly discuss the case of Phillips, who was summonsed by Gorham police on a charge of operating under the influence in May. The council also argued over whether Phillips should be allowed to participate in council agenda items involving the Gorham Police Department. The council also declined to accept a letter of resignation from Philip Gagnon, vice chairman.

Comments are no longer available on this story