3 min read

In some corporate boardroom somewhere, men (they always tend to be men) are seated around a large mahogany table deciding your future, your family’s future, and the nation’s future.

Let us hope that the decisions they privately make will help all of us live better lives. Let us hope they are contemplating ways to ease suffering and propagate democracy and self-sufficiency throughout the world.

In some cases they are. In other cases, however, their decisions inflict suffering though they may improve lives for a select few. And, in some cases these decisions involve running roughshod over sovereign citizens who are simply exercising their right to property ownership and self-preservation.

Take, for example, Krista and James Bostford of North Dakota. They were approached by the oil pipeline company Enbridge with an offer to buy a right-of-way to build the Sandpiper Pipeline through their family farm. The Bostfords declined, but Enbridge kept calling, several times daily, like an annoying telemarketer. “Look,” he finally told them, “we’re not going to sign, so why don’t you just go around us?” But, in 2013, Enbridge obtained a restraining order on the Bostfords to give surveyors unimpeded open access to their land to complete their surveys. Enbridge is now forcing the right to condemn and seize part of the Bostfords’ land under eminent domain. James Bostford is a retired lawyer, and so he knew how to fight back. The case is going to court and jury selection begins this month.

“No” was apparently not strong enough. “We’re Enbridge,” Mr. Bostford recalls of their last conversation, “we don’t go around anything, we go through it.”

The Bostfords’ refusal was on principle – something money can’t buy. That principle is the right of a landowner to preserve his natural land in the face of bullying by a large (in this case, foreign) corporation – a corporation whose business model exacerbates climate change rather than promotes sustainability and that, ultimately, causes more suffering than it relieves. Bostford is no hippie zealot. “We drive cars and so forth,” Mr. Bostford acknowledges, ”but when life presents you with an opportunity to take a stand, we felt compelled to take a stand.”

Advertisement

Private decisions become pubic decisions when others’ lives are affected. But why does Enbridge have the upper hand at this intersection between private and public interests?

We all know the answer: big corporations can unleash an army of highly paid lawyers to use the legal system to their distinct advantage every time. Pay-to-play justice steamrolls the little guy who lacks the time, the singular life devotion, and the endless well of money to fight back.

Folksy wisdom has echoed over the past 40 years that government is too big and intrusive and must be stopped. Sure, we have all witnessed bad government of some sort – instances of eye-rolling incompetence, profligate inefficiency, or some measure of bullying, say, from an unjust parking ticket to much, much worse. These experiences of bad government help feed a distrust and distaste for government generally.

But bullying of the Bostfords is from the private sector, not the government. Here, a government of, by and for the people should be the Bostfords’ bodyguard rather than Enbridge’s enabler.

Sometimes it is easy to be cynical about the fate of democracy, but there is hope. Local city governments in Maine, as with some 30 other states, possess wide-ranging authority under home rule. Home rule authority can be deployed by an activated “we the people” to effectively fight back against private sector bullying. Diligence and strategic planning by elected city officers can stake a solid claim, well-founded in the western legal tradition and our constitutional culture, that can withstand corporate malevolence of the type the Bostfords know.

Sometimes corporations forget that the commitment to the whole population – down to the individual – might not be best served by the private coterie of men making private decisions around a mahogany table. Democratic governance – good governance – is an ongoing experiment to be built from the bottom up, not from the top down. Take ownership of your own democracy experiment, and this fall election season, consider the unrealized power of your local government to be your bodyguard.

Eben Rose lives in South Portland.

Comments are no longer available on this story