4 min read

The red signs are up, and the glossies are out. The architecture rendition drawings are displayed prominently in all the schools. It seems we’re being marketed to at taxpayer expense, paid for by me, a taxpayer, on something I don’t support. And the worst part is the information is both misleading and false.

I started getting annoyed more than six months ago, when a statement was made by a school board member that supporting a $55 million dollar school project was a “no brainer.” Using the term “no brainer” to the voting public suggests that if anyone had any brains in their head, they’d for sure, jump up and vote for this, no questions asked. This comment alone disturbed me.

Wondering exactly where my brains were at – because, shame on me, I hadn’t grasped that I should be joining this spending frenzy campaign – I decided to do what you would hope people would do; go into study hall to really wrap my arms around this very costly proposal. And then ask some serious questions.

I believe our country, state, and town, are obligated to provide our children with a quality public education. I have, however, agonized over why Scarborough taxpayers should have to foot this entire bill. Why not the state?

The answer has become quite clear. It’s because we want more than everyone else, we want it now, and we don’t want to wait our turn. I looked at all three of these points and thought: what on earth are we really teaching our children here? Are we spoiling them? If we give them the new Mercedes, will they ever be able to compromise for the 10 year old car when the going gets tough?

The going is tough. Maine, as a total state, is losing its younger population. Of the school age populations left, they are shifting and moving around. It is true that they are moving to Scarborough, and that the numbers in the schools are for the most part, stable. But, we have been accommodating them with portables. Though it isn’t perfect, life isn’t perfect. The portables haven’t compromised their quality of education. Sure, it may be inconvenient. But life isn’t always convenient.

Advertisement

Our kids should get in line with everyone else. But somehow, that mentality hasn’t resonated with our school board. In a joint meeting of the town council and school board on Dec. 15 2005, speaking about Wentworth school, former Superintendent William Michaud said, “That particular building would be a prize in many districts. When we look at other buildings here, it doesn’t measure up.” That comment leads to my next thought: What message are we sending to the state?

Scarborough hasn’t gotten state funding because there are other schools ahead of us on the list. As other school districts lose students, the need to fund school projects in those towns go away. Close to home, Portland’s school age population has dropped so drastically, that they are actually considering closing three elementary schools.

As the state talks regionalization and consolidation to reduce the cost of education, and as school districts make demographic shifts in student populations, I’m left with two thoughts: 1. Be patient and wait our turn for the state to fund our school projects. 2. Consider renting an abandoned school in the greater Portland area to create an alternative learning environment for different learning styles.

Beyond the brains in my head, I look at the money in my wallet. An education I give my kids every day is that you don’t spend money without carefully thinking about what you’re buying and what this will cost you over the long haul. Don’t be excessive. Immediate gratification bought on credit is sinful. Being up front and honest is critical. And, finally, good things come to those who wait.

Contrary to what the glossies say, the town council didn’t unanimously approve the school board proposal to fund the two school projects. Rather, they unanimously agreed that we, the taxpayers, should vote on this bond issue. The tax implications are misleading too; they are cumulative, and the average home price in Scarborough is actually $371,600 not $289,800. So, how much have these marketing materials cost taxpayers?

As school age populations continue to shift, we must consider the cost to live here. If Scarborough approves these two bond issues, it sends a bad message to our kids and to the state: We’re wealthy and better than everyone else; we don’t need any state funding. We’ll continue to fall lower on the state funding priority list. The state will forget about Scarborough because the message is clear: history has proven that if you don’t give them what they want when they want it, they’ll fund it themselves. Eventually, the cost to live here will be so cost prohibitive to families of school age children that they’ll shift out of our town. This “no brainer” looks more like a big drainer to me. Vote no on both school projects.

Comments are no longer available on this story