4 min read

WINDHAM – Two weeks after he defended himself against fraud charges at a press conference held in his Windham home, Rent-A-Husband’s Kaile Warren said he wants to make the same case before the Cumberland County grand jury, the body that indicted him last December.

Facing a pending trial on charges he fraudulently solicited investments for his handyman company, Warren feels strongly that the grand jury would dismiss charges if he is given a chance to speak.

The Maine Attorney General’s office is considering the request. But the assistant attorney general prosecuting the case, Leanne Robbin, pointed out that Warren was already allowed to present his case when he was deposed twice last year.

Warren is charged with a class B felony charge of theft by deception, and two class C charges of securities fraud and sale of unregistered securities. A jury trial could start as early as May. If convicted Warren could face 10 years in prison.

In a letter sent last week to Maine Attorney General Janet Mills, Warren wrote: “I am being falsely accused of crime. I request that I be allowed to testify before the grand jury which is investigating me and Rent-A-Husband. I understand the grand jury sits in Cumberland County again in March. If permitted, I will come before the grand jury and answer all questions put to me by the state and individual jury members. I will also produce documentation supporting my answers. I will not have a lawyer with me in the grand jury room.”

In the letter, Warren goes on to criticize the grand jury process and beseech the attorney general to hear both sides of the case, writing, “The grand jury does everything in secret (at a time when most people think that government should be transparent). This is an invitation for incredible testimony. That is why I want an invitation to testify before the Grand Jury and answer all questions put to me – truthfully.”

Advertisement

Warren, who is represented by Portland attorney Dan Lilley, said he knows going before the grand jury has its risks, but he and Lilley are confident it would help prove his innocence. Warren also said he is a “very aggressive and proactive person” who lives his life “with a sense of urgency. Obviously the government is bringing some very serious charges and it’s a total injustice what they are doing.”

If allowed a chance to appear, Warren said, he would present documents that he believes prove negligence on the part of Preti Flaherty, the Portland-based law that drew up investment contracts with Rent-A-Husband’s numerous investors.

Warren said he would also show printouts of e-mails he received from Ace Hardware executives as late as Feb. 3, 2009, that he said show an ongoing relationship between his handyman company and the hardware store chain. The state’s case partly revolves around the question of whether Warren lured potential investors knowing a proposed venture with Ace Hardware was dead.

“What I’d be doing is basically laying out our defense by producing many documents that speak for themselves,” Warren said.

In appearing, Warren would waive his rights to having a lawyer present as well as his right to remain silent according to the 5th Amendment.

“I’m willing to do those things, however, to show I’m innocent,” he said.

Advertisement

Whether Warren is allowed to appear is a decision that only Mills can make. Robbin, who is in charge of financial crime and civil rights for the Attorney General’s Office, said a decision has yet to be made regarding Warren’s ability to speak when the Cumberland County grand jury reconvenes in March. She also said the department would not publicize its decision. Only Warren could disclose his appearance, she said.

Speaking in generalities, Robbin said the purpose of a grand jury is simply to determine probable cause. While defendants are not usually invited to speak at grand jury hearings, there are rare exceptions, but Robbin was unwilling to speculate whether Warren would be allowed the chance to address the grand jury.

The attorney general’s office, however, did say that Warren was fully deposed in May and November of 2009 and, in that process, was allowed to state his case.

“Well, gosh, he was absolutely fully deposed. He gave testimony before the Maine Office of Securities, before criminal charges were ever brought,” Robbin said.

Warren, who declined to elaborate on his two depositions, said his case “is getting so much bigger” and will get even bigger when his legal team reveals documentation regarding their case.

“In time, when the facts are out – that Preti Flaherty gave poor advice, and how Ace is now treating me like an unwanted relative when all along they invested tens of thousands of dollars into Rent-A-Husband – it’ll be clear that I am innocent. I’m not intending to stop until I arrest this injustice,” Warren said.

Advertisement

Both Ace Hardware and Preti-Flaherty have issued limited press releases on the matter. Ace denied having a business relationship with Warren after “early 2008,” and Preti Flaherty said it has not represented Warren for two years and that Warren seems to be attributing his legal difficulties to the “actions of this law firm, and not to his own.”

“Ace’s legal department would be all over me if what I’m saying isn’t true. The truth is, their actions are defenseless. And as a result you see them hiding under their desks,” Warren said, adding, “People don’t do what I’m doing if they are guilty.”

Asked if he was considering suing Ace, Warren said, “I’m not ruling it out.”

Even if he manages to appear before the grand jury and sway them to his side, Warren said the damage already done to his reputation and that of his company may be irreparable.

“Unfortunately the damage that an indictment can do to one’s reputation can oftentimes be insurmountable,” he said. “But I am an innocent person and I’m just trying to stop the injustice.”

Comments are no longer available on this story