Off-base estimates for repair and improvement work at the Scarborough Public Library brought Director Nancy Crowell under fire from town councilors May 21, as the council finalized its $19.5 million municipal budget for the coming year.
Some councilors said they were shocked that Crowell, who last year asked for several hundred thousand dollars in capital improvement funding, had since discovered that her estimates for about a half-dozen projects were grossly inadequate. Crowell was seeking about $410,000 more to complete the problems.
“I’m not against taking care of the building at all,” said Councilor Richard Sullivan, who brought the issue to the Town Council’s attention as the board was about to finalize next year’s budget. “I want a request that’s close to what’s expected … just like all of the other departments do.”
Other councilors, however, said the timing of Sullivan’s criticism troubled them. Sullivan had attended numerous budget workshops as a member of the Finance Committee before challenging Crowell’s capital requests at the council’s publicly televised budget finalization meeting.
“I’m very troubled by the tone (of the comments),” Councilor Sylvia Most said. “Suggesting impropriety – I think it is very troubling.”
Crowell said in an interview after the meeting that she was also “surprised at the timing” of the comments.
Sullivan has said he was not suggesting any impropriety.
Projects for which Crowell requested additional funding include a new parking lot and landscaping, approved last year at $40,000 and now estimated to cost an additional $100,000; interior and exterior painting, approved last year at $20,000 and now estimated to cost an additional $50,000; brickwork repairs approved at $12,000 and now estimated to cost an additional $45,000; and window and millwork repairs, approved last year at $75,000 and now estimated to cost an additional $75,000.
“To be (so far) off on an estimate, to me – I’m troubled by that,” Chairman Jeffrey Messer said.
He said the library was the only town department that did not submit narratives explaining its capital improvement requests.
“Come forward in another year when you have an accurate estimate,” he said.
Admittedly “defensive,” Crowell said last year’s estimates were based on information available at the time, after a $16.5 million referendum to build a major addition to the library failed. She said that when the library sought to hire contractors to do the work, she discovered the funds approved last year were inadequate.
Councilor Michael Wood, who earlier had praised the library and asked the council to add back $20,000 that had been cut from the library budget, also took Crowell to task.
“I’ll say what Nancy won’t say, and I mean no disrespect – Nancy blew the estimate,” he said. “You need to do some research, Nancy, instead of estimating these.”
Crowell mouthed softly, “I concur.”
Councilors said they would support including the work in next year’s budget process, or even as an out-of-budget expenditure in 2008-2009, if library staff could come up with reliable cost estimates.
“We need a little more than a guesstimate, or even an estimate,” Councilor Ron Alquist said.
The council voted unanimously to cut $75,000 for a library backup generator and $75,000 for office reconfiguration from the new capital improvement budget. The council also voted 5-2 to cut $100,000 for parking and $75,000 for window and millwork repair (councilors Judith Roy and Carol Rancourt opposed); 4-3 to remove $50,000 for painting (Roy, Rancourt and Sylvia Most opposed); and 3-4 to keep $45,000 to clean and repair the brick walls in the budget (Wood, Roy, Rancourt and Most in favor of funding the work).
Town Manager Ron Owens said the cuts will have no effect on next year’s tax rate because capital improvements are funded by municipal bonds that the town pays back over a period of years or decades, and the first payment on any bonds would have been incurred in the 2009-2010 tax year.
In an interview after the meeting, Crowell said the estimates provided to the Town Council last year were intended as a “place-holder” that, once the work was approved, would allow her to go out and get more accurate estimates from contractors. She said seeking bids for work that had not been approved would have put her in an “ethical dilemma.” She also said the comparison of the library’s capital improvement budget to other departments’ budgets was “unfair.”
“This isn’t a piece of fire apparatus that you can go out and get a standard bid price from a consortium or a dealer,” she said. “These are construction projects.”
She said she plans to submit revised estimates as soon as possible.
“It’s not a major setback. I think it’s clear that we need to repair the building,” she said. “I think they are eager for more information that’s as accurate as possible, and we’ll certainly provide that to them. We respect the investment that the taxpayers have made, and we’re not going to let it deteriorate.”
Despite their ire over the off-base estimates, several councilors expressed their support for the library. At Wood’s request, they added back $20,000 of the $35,000 they earlier cut from the library’s 2008-2009 operating budget.
“The library affects everyone in town,” said Rancourt. “I think the literature and books and research materials are going to be used more than ever (due to the poor economy).”
Messer, however, said the library is hardly hurting for funds. Eleven years ago, he said, its budget was $431,000; now, it’s $856,000.
“I think the library will do quite well with a budget that’s doubled in 11 years,” he said.
At Wednesday’s meeting, the council made a few other last-minute budget changes, decreasing the fee for food-handler licenses from $220 per year to $100 and adding $50,000 to the school budget, which it had earlier cut by $925,000. The $50,000 will be raised by “user fees” imposed on athletes and will not affect the tax rate.
Comments are no longer available on this story