5 min read

NAPLES – Due to a mistake made during last year’s construction of the Naples Causeway, work crews were out again this week repaving about a half-mile stretch of Route 302 in downtown Naples.

According to Craig Hurd, resident engineer for Maine Department of Transportation, the 6 inches of new pavement installed from the intersection of Route 114 to just south of the new bridge near Merced’s Restaurant failed density tests last fall. The cause of the problem, he said, remains a mystery, and the two pavement contractors, Pike Industries and Rampart Bituminous, are disputing which would cover the estimated $100,000-plus fix.

Pike, which is based in Belmont, N.H., and Rampart, based in Windham, both declined to comment. Hurd said he didn’t know whether the matter has been settled but that taxpayers wouldn’t be on the hook for the second paving treatment.

“Rampart Bituminous did the paving, and Pike supplied the mix. So I’m not really sure who’s to blame. No one really knows what the real problem was, but they have to fix it,” Hurd said. When asked which company will cover the costs, Hurd said, “Well, we’re not paying. That’s all I know.”

Wyman & Simpson, based in Richmond, is the general contractor for the project in Naples. Owner Jeff Simpson said paving is part art, part science.

“There’s a lot that goes into it, between the ingredients that go into it – the asphalt, the stone, the sand – and temperature has something to do with it, as far as weather, when we put it down. That’s why we can’t pave in [cold weather]. Plus the rollers and compactors that follow behind the pavers, that all plays a role in the performance and durability of the pavement itself,” he said.

Advertisement

The second round of paving, which started Monday with the grinding of the top 11?2 inches of pavement, has pushed back the project’s targeted completion date. That conflicts, however, with the expectation laid out in the state’s contract with the town of Naples that mandates roadwork must cease by Memorial Day, when the summer tourist season ramps up. Simpson said that deadline could be in jeopardy due to the paving setback.

“We’ve done it once, you certainly don’t want to have to do it again, but we have to. And being restricted on when you can pave kind of puts us in a bind since it takes X amount of days to grind it up, and X amount of days to pave it back in, and a few more days to restripe it,” he said. “So we’re pushing ourselves right to the limit as far as when we want this thing to be done on Memorial Day. But we’ll make it, as long as the weather cooperates.”

If weather doesn’t allow for paving to continue, there could be financial damages, but “that’s yet to be determined,” Simpson said. “They can hit us with liquidated damages if they feel we didn’t make a good-faith effort, but we’ll get it done.”

The entire project, which commenced in October 2010 and was scheduled for completion in May 2013, should be completed by mid-July, Hurd said. He said the major remaining project is painting the cement facade on the new bridge. Workers will apply a stain resembling natural granite for the larger stone sections and another stain that resembles grout in between.

Simpson said the need to repave is a setback in what has otherwise been a successful project. The new fixed bridge, which spans the Chute River between Long Lake and Brandy Pond, is working well and trees, shrubs and grass are in the process of being installed in a green space beside the new bridge. The work is being completed this week by Portland-based Sabra Property Care, and overseen by Kent Cooper, landscape architect with the Maine Department of Transportation.

“They dug out probably two feet of gravel and put in new loam and topsoil and nice new sod and plantings,” Cooper said of the work in the green space beside the new bridge. “We’ve been planting some white birch and Japanese tree lilac and rosa ragosa, some snowball bush, some lilacs, so we have a nice long flowering sequence, lots of pretty things for people to look at while they’re walking around the causeway.”

Advertisement

Many of the plants have been installed near an amphitheater overlooking Brandy Pond. There have also been Japanese tree lilac and American basswood trees planted along the boardwalk, which runs from the bridge past the Songo River Queen II’s dock to Sandy’s Flight Deck on the northern edge of the causeway project. The trees are expected to grow 45 feet tall and provide shade for the sun-drenched causeway. A lone elm tree, which Cooper said could grow up to 90 feet tall, has been planted next to the bridge.

The boardwalk, which features stamped brown-colored concrete designed to resemble wood, has also proven difficult to successfully install, said Simpson, of Wyman & Simpson. He said chipping and discoloration began last year and that sections were in need of replacement. One large section was already replaced.

“We’ve had problems throughout that boardwalk, but we think we’ve got it figured out. It had to do with the type of sealer that was recommended to use on it, and we’ve since changed the method of applying it, and it seems to be working better,” he said.

Despite the slowdown and changes, Bob Neault, chairman of the Causeway Restoration Committee, which worked with the state to design all aspects of the estimated $7 million project using input from Naples residents, is excited to see the long-sought project nearing completion.

“We worked real hard to try to make sure we had appropriate materials and contractors involved, and to have it come down to this, with a year later we’re jack-hammering stuff out, is a little disheartening,” he said. “But once again, the contractors are stepping up and saying they’re going to make it right. So, that says a lot for them and all the parties involved.”

Neault said there will be a celebration on Sunday, May 26 – Memorial Day weekend – open to Naples residents with food and music and acting at the newly finished amphitheater. There will also be fireworks at 9:30 p.m.

The paving delay, he said, “is something that happens and you just have to deal with it. The important thing is they’re taking care of the problem. It’s really starting to take shape, and I think we have a lot to be proud of.”

Taking advantage of good weather, workers place sod and shrubs along the Naples Causeway in the area of the new amphitheater on Monday.

Comments are no longer available on this story