The Scarborough Board of Education added five new positions to next year’s proposed budget in a 4-to-3 vote last week.
The new positions would cost $200,000. However, they will not affect the $27.4 million bottom line of the proposed budget.
In his initial budget projections, Superintendent Bill Michaud over estimated what the district would have to pay in insurance spending next year by $200,000. He expected the district’s insurance costs to rise by $300,000. Instead, they will rise by only $100,000.
Board members Dianne Messer, Chairman Robert Mitchell and Chris Brownsey voted against the additional positions. Board members David Beneman, Jackie Perry, Paul Foster and Colleen Staszko voted in favor of it.
The five new positions are for student support, which the district had identified as a need. The positions will be added at every level – primary, intermediate, middle and high school, as well as special education.
The board had been discussing adding new positions to the budget before it learned schools would be paying less than expected for insurance. During the board’s meeting in late February, district administrators presented the positions they would like to add to the budget. In total, they identified 13 new positions that would have cost $687,000.
Beneman said the initial budget lacked some of the things he wanted in it. In fact, he said he would have recommended the board increase the budget by $220,000 to include some additional positions anyway.
“It strikes me that these five positions are entirely in line with what we are trying to achieve as a district,” Beneman said.
Perry said the board should focus on students and the district’s educational needs and then on the costs. “Our responsibility is to present a budget to educate the children,” she said. “I think that’s what we are doing.”
Staszko said she felt better including the five positions in the budget. “If you are a parent of a child that needs support, you probably are not looking for the best value from your school budget. You are looking for that support,” she said.
Chairman Bob Mitchell, who voted against the additions, said the board was working with a proposed budget and was concerned that it would appear it was back filling the initial budget request.
Chris Brownsey said the budget’s 7.1 percent increase is higher than last year’s increase and it is at the upper level of what he felt the Town Council would approve.
“I think it would be difficult for me to add all $200,000 of positions in the budget,” he said.
Beneman countered that the budget’s increase is being driven by inflationary measures, such as pay increases, and once they are backed out of the budget there is no increase in discretionary spending.
“We set-up ourselves as a district to never have improvement,” he said.
Comments are no longer available on this story