As one of the many fortunate students who spent a year in Dwight Ely’s history class, I write on behalf of all of us to thank you for the article and synopsis of Mr. Ely’s speech at this year’s Cape Elizabeth High School graduation (The Current, June 14).
Mr. Ely is one of the rare educators whose passion, intellect, and demeanor is one students revere, while in his class and for years afterward. I believe that his personal, thought-provoking, and unique speech is profound evidence of the admirable teacher that he has always been. A testament to his incredible teaching ability and style is that, though we all studied under him, we never knew what he was thinking.
I remember taking Mr Ely’s senior history class when we studied the Vietnam War, and in particular, one assignment where we students had to ponder the question “Why Vietnam?” In small groups, we were to build upon the facts and foreign policy we had studied in class, and then write our own interpretation of Vietnam. A still-challenging and controversial subject, I recall spending the first of many late nights (here again, Mr. Ely gave us great preparation for college) writing, rewriting, and re-thinking this topic.
On the day of the class presentations, each group presented and defended their thoughts and rationale of America’s decisions and actions in the Vietnam War. Though I do not recall any of the other group’s responses, this I will never forget: Mr Ely sitting in the back of his classroom, his omnipresent glasses halfway down his nose, listening and occasionally nodding or shaking his head, ever so slightly. Always searching for the right answer, hoping always to be the one who had it, I remember asking Mr. Ely if my group’s response was the correct one. As is his signature, instead of a yes or no, he said, “I don’t know. What do you think?”
Years have passed since our 1998 Cape Elizabeth High School graduation, and Mr. Ely has left an indelible imprint on many lives. Due in no small part to Mr Ely’s instruction and his ability to impart his own intellectual curiosity onto his students, I majored in political science and international relations at Williams College. While there, I experienced some of our generation’s most significant national events: the contentious first election of George W. Bush, the ongoing genocide in Rwanda, the world-changing event of Sept. 11, 2001. With wide eyes, I analyzed these events, never forgetting Mr. Ely’s paramount question: “Why?” As my generation struggles with the foreign policy agenda of the past and present administration, this question becomes the panacea which can help us to create our, hopefully benevolent, legacy.
It is rare in a student’s development that she will come across a teacher as motivating, brilliant, and influential as Dwight Ely. This explains why, when she receives a copy of the article, she immediately scans it and sends it to her classmates, who respond with similar enthusiasm. The public admission of Mr. Ely’s long-kept personal opinion and insight into a subject that he teaches so well is evidence of his incredible prowess as an educator. After all these years of never knowing how he felt, it is an honor and such an exceptional event to hear Mr. Ely respond to his own, extremely challenging, assignment. If I were the one giving out the grades, he would have earned himself what he so rarely doles out, an A.
Amanda Gramse
Boston, Mass.
Comments are no longer available on this story