SOUTH PORTLAND – The Portland International Jetport needs to lengthen its secondary runway to meet air safety standards. To do that, the jetport needs approval from the city of South Portland because the runway expansion would be on land the jetport owns in the city.
However, it wasn’t clear at a recent City Council workshop whether there was enough support from councilors for the zoning change the jetport needs to proceed with its plans for the expansion.
Although jetport officials assured them that the expanded runway would get little use, councilors raised concerns that the expansion could create noise problems, if not now, then in the future.
“What I’m worried about is what’s going to happen in 10 or 15 years…and we’re looking at this and saying, ‘Oh gee, we shouldn’t have done this,'” said Councilor James Hughes.
The 1,100-foot expansion of the 5,001-foot runway would move the runway and its associated noise closer to Brick Hill, a new housing and office complex near the jetport, and to the Redbank neighborhood, councilors said.
Hughes said he would not support the expansion. Two other councilors, Patti Smith and Maxine Beecher, said they were undecided. Councilors Linda Boudreau and Tom Coward, as well as Mayor Tom Blake, expressed only reluctant support for the issue.
Rosemarie De Angelis, a new councilor elected in November, won’t be sworn in until Dec. 7 so did not take part in the discussion.
At the council workshop on Nov. 23, Blake summed up the council’s stance for Paul Bradbury, airport director.
“The council has serious noise concerns,” Blake said. “I’m not sure where we are going from here.”
City Manager James Gailey said this week that the city will “keep the door open for future discussions” with the jetport regarding the proposed expansion and council concerns. Blake said the issue is not likely to return to the council for at least a month.
The council in April approved rezoning the jetport property as light industrial. That zoning would allow for future runway expansion.
However, according to Gailey, the council also added a stipulation that specifically prohibited runway expansion until the jetport had further discussed its plans for a longer runway with the council. If the council were satisfied, it then would vote to remove the stipulation and allow the rezoning plan to be complete.
The jetport is now asking the council to remove the stipulation. Bradbury made a presentation of the jetport’s plans at the council workshop. If it wins council approval for the zoning, the proposed expansion still must gain South Portland Planning Board approval.
Bradbury said the expansion, also called a runway safety area, is mandated by the federal government to take place by the end of 2015.
Too-short runways have proved to be dangerous, Bradbury said. Over the past 10 years, 75 aircraft have either overrun or veered off runways across the nation, resulting in nearly 200 injuries and 12 deaths, according to national data he presented.
In 2010, the jetport needs to do a major reconstruction of its secondary runway, which hasn’t been reconstructed since 1989. The newly reconstructed runway must have the required extra length of safety.
Bradbury said the secondary runway serves only small regional and business jet aircraft, with larger planes using the airport’s longer main runway.
Because airlines are finding small regional jets too expensive to operate, their number has dropped from 25 per day on the runway in the summer of 2007 to 15 per day the summer of 2009, he said.
Bradbury predicted those regional jets will remain too expensive for the runway to see much use in the future.
“Trust me, it’s not coming back,” Bradbury said of small, regional airline traffic.
According to a report the jetport prepared for the council earlier this year, the secondary runway does have occasional use by larger planes when the main runway is closed for maintenance. It also gets used by other aircraft when strong crosswinds blowing from the north or south make it safer to use the secondary runway. That runway runs north and south, while the main runway runs east and west.
Having a longer runway would make it safer when other aircraft had to land on the secondary runway for emergency situations, the report said.
Bradbury said that while the extension will be 1,100 feet, the actual amount of new pavement used by the planes will only be an additional 600 feet. He said that’s because all take-offs and landings must take place at a certain point and the extra 500 feet is just a safety measure in case a plane needs extra pavement in an emergency.
The expansion proposal shifts the runway south, and Boudreau questioned whether that was to benefit residents of the Stroudwater neighborhood in Portland. The neighborhood is situated at the northern end of the runway and residents there are vocal opponents of airport noise.
Boudreau wondered if Stroudwater residents had complained about noise from the runway and the jetport had said, “We’ll move it south and close to the residents of Brick Hill.”
Bradbury said the runway can only be shifted south because the Fore River is to the north and the pavement can’t be expanded that way. He said take-offs – which he said are noisier than landings – will continue to take place in the same spot on the runway as they do now. That take-off location remains close to Stroudwater, he said.
Bradbury said that while the longer runway would be closer to South Portland neighborhoods, the noise would remain largely within airport boundaries. And, he said, the noise would be sporadic, not continuous.
Hughes asked about an alternative to lengthening the runway – an alternative called an engineered materials arresting system, or EMAS. That involves putting up high energy absorbing materials as barriers that will crush under the weight of an aircraft and stop it.
Bradbury said that could add $1 million or more to the project, which now is estimated to cost $10 million. And he said he doubted it would get Federal Aviation Administration approval. That agency prefers that alternative only if land isn’t available for a runway extension, Bradbury said.
Hughes responded: “We can make that land not available.”
Councilors asked about sound walls being put up, but Bradbury said such barriers are a hazard. “When pilots are landing and taking off, they don’t want a brick wall in front of them,” he said.
But Blake suggested that a noise barrier to the west of the expanded runway wouldn’t be hazardous.
Boudreau noted that she lives on Sawyer Street in the east end of the city, where much of the airport noise is focused as planes fly over houses. However, she said, airport noise has decreased about 25 percent in three decades. “I will support this,” she said. “We live near an airport.”
Coward, who said 98 percent of the jetport’s planes fly over his home on Woodbury Street, said the council didn’t seem to have much choice. “We’re faced with a mandate. We either have to do this or else move the airport.”
He added, “I look at this as essentially the emergency runway, the alternative runway.”
Blake said, “I’m going to be supporting this but I do have some concerns.” He added: “We’re in a quandary. We’re stuck with an airport in an urban area.”
Comments are no longer available on this story