WESTBROOK – The question of creating a commission to review Westbrook’s charter generated intense debate among the city’s Municipal’s Officers last year.
Even their vote last fall to place the question on the ballot this month was a divided decision. Some officials argued a commission is necessary to review the way the city’s strong mayor form of government works, and others contended the system isn’t broken and doesn’t need fixing.
But now that Westbrook residents are about to go to the polls on Tuesday to decide on whether to form such a commission, debate on the issue seems to have died down.
City Clerk Lynda Adams said she is not aware of any political action committees that have formed on either side of the ballot question.
“Nobody has really strongly come out,” she said.
The lack of debate now may simply be a repeat of last year – when there was a lack of public participation as the Municipal Officers, who are the seven city councilors and the mayor, debated the necessity of forming a charter commission.
In fact, former longtime Mayor Bruce Chuluda, a charter commission opponent, said at the time that the fact that city residents didn’t turn out to discuss the issue was an indication that they didn’t care about it.
He said on Wednesday that he feels “shock and dismay” that the issue is now before voters without a thorough pre-election public debate.
“I remain opposed to the need to create a commission or the need to play with the city charter,” Chuluda said. “I think the way it works is just fine.”
However, Brendan Rielly, City Council president and a charter commission proponent, said Wednesday that he believes residents remain concerned about establishing clear lines of authority in city government and want a review of that.
“It has gotten kind of quiet,” Rielly admitted about the lack of signs and debate as Election Day approaches.
However, he said, that is because the vote by Municipal Officers to put the issue on the June ballot was made months ago, early last fall.
Rielly said he believes that forming a charter commission still remains a relevant issue because he said he has “heard people talking about some of the same concerns that prompted us to send this out to vote.”
The question before city voters on Tuesday will read: “Shall a Charter Commission be established for the purposes of revising the City Charter or establishing a new City Charter?”
If voters decide to form a commission, it would have nine members. The council would appoint three members and six would be elected by voters at the polls this November.
The commission would decide for itself what aspects of the charter it wants to review. Any changes the commission recommends would be subject to voter approval.
However, Rielly said that he and other Municipal Officers who voted to send the charter commission question to voters have some ideas about what the commission should look at.
He said their message to the commission would be: “Here are some of the reasons we sent this out for a vote and we’d love it if you’d look at them.”
He said there are two overarching reasons the charter should be reviewed.
One, he said, is simply to make minor changes to the charter, such as cleaning up archaic language. For example, he said, the charter still refers to city “aldermen,” a title for city officials that no longer exists.
But the larger reason why he and others want the commission to review the charter has to do with the authority of the mayor and the City Council.
Westbrook is among a handful of Maine communities to have an elected mayor with strong powers. The Westbrook mayor by charter has the authority to hire and fire all city employees.
The city also has a strong City Council, Rielly said. “We’re the ones who have to enact policy. We’re the ones who have to deal with personnel,” he said.
He said the division of powers can create “confusion” for a resident who has an issue with a city employee. Residents typically turn to their councilors first, who may try to resolve the issue between the resident and the employee.
However, Rielly said, “at the end of the day that person doesn’t work for us … (and) if the mayor disagrees, we’re in a difficult position.”
Rielly also said that because city employees answer to the mayor, they could be put in a difficult position if the council passes a policy that the mayor disagrees with. The employees then must implement a policy that their boss doesn’t like, he said.
Comments are no longer available on this story